| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1876 47-23 | Fallow 28-10, 1.85 | Williams 18-12, 2.88 | Mielke 1-1, 0.67 | | | Fallow 2 SV, 1.85 | Fallow 41 G, 1.85 | Williams 35 G, 2.88 | Mielke 6 G, 0.67 | | 1877 31-29 | Kelly 19-13, 2.94 | Williams 12-16, 3.82 | Mielke 0-0, 6.00 | | | Mielke 1 SV, 6.00 | Kelly 40 G, 2.94 | Williams 34 G, 3.82 | Mielke 3 G, 6.00 | | 1878 20-40 | Courtney 5-12, 3.11 | Kelly 8-10, 2.42 | Bryant 4-11, 4.33 | Riddick 3-6, 2.28 | Hearns 0-1, 3.65 | Bryant 1 SV, 4.33 | Kelly 26 G, 2.42 | Courtney 25 G, 3.11 | Bryant 20 G, 4.33 | | 1879 41-43 | Riddick 26-18, 2.59 | Pitchford 15-25, 3.02 | Canning 0-0, 8.82 | Powell 0-0, 0.00 | | Pitchford 1 SV, 3.02 | Riddick 45 G, 2.59 | Pitchford 43 G, 3.02 | Canning 7 G, 8.82 | | 1880 33-52 | Riddick 18-26, 2.98 | Fallow 15-26, 3.36 | McCart 0-0, 0.00 | | | Fallow 0 SV, 3.36 | Riddick 49 G, 2.98 | Fallow 48 G, 3.36 | McCart 5 G, 0.00 | | 1881 45-38 | Riddick 42-33, 2.79 | OBrien 1-4, 4.56 | Pitchford 2-1, 4.83 | | | OBrien 2 SV, 4.56 | Riddick 77 G, 2.79 | OBrien 21 G, 4.56 | Pitchford 12 G, 4.83 | | 1882 44-40 | Riddick 25-19, 2.42 | OBrien 18-19, 3.39 | Hartley 0-0, 0.00 | Lynn 1-2, 5.87 | | Lynn 2 SV, 5.87 | Riddick 45 G, 2.42 | OBrien 40 G, 3.39 | Lynn 19 G, 5.87 | | 1883 62-36 | Lynn 26-8, 2.13 | OBrien 22-10, 2.46 | Davis 14-18, 3.62 | | | Davis 0 SV, 3.62 | OBrien 42 G, 2.46 | Lynn 36 G, 2.13 | Davis 32 G, 3.62 | | 1884 75-40 | OBrien 27-14, 2.51 | Lynn 32-8, 1.63 | Davis 15-17, 3.45 | Scott 0-0, 1.84 | Simpson 0-0, 9.00 | Thorpe 1 SV, 2.57 | OBrien 43 G, 2.51 | Lynn 40 G, 1.63 | Davis 32 G, 3.45 | | 1885 40-73 | Crutchfield 13-20, 3.69 | OBrien 12-24, 3.73 | Cannon 11-22, 3.77 | Atkins 0-0, 5.23 | Bey 1-2, 1.23 | Bey 2 SV, 1.23 | Crutchfield 40 G, 3.69 | OBrien 38 G, 3.73 | Cannon 35 G, 3.77 | |