| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1882 43-31 | Allerton 7-17, 2.65 | Whitman 19-8, 2.22 | Hearns 17-6, 2.59 | | | Whitman 2 SV, 2.22 | Whitman 34 G, 2.22 | Allerton 28 G, 2.65 | Hearns 25 G, 2.59 | | 1883 43-53 | Earle 8-24, 3.90 | Mulligan 16-16, 2.16 | Pitchford 18-13, 1.85 | Bonnie 0-0, 0.00 | Smallwood 1-0, 19.29 | Mulligan 1 SV, 2.16 | Mulligan 39 G, 2.16 | Pitchford 37 G, 1.85 | Earle 35 G, 3.90 | | 1884 64-27 | Roper 35-13, 1.60 | Pitchford 28-14, 1.95 | Foster 1-0, 2.70 | Vogel 0-0, 2.25 | | Foster 1 SV, 2.70 | Roper 49 G, 1.60 | Pitchford 42 G, 1.95 | Foster 7 G, 2.70 | | 1885 78-34 | Roper 28-10, 1.29 | Pitchford 23-11, 1.55 | Young 22-12, 1.88 | Bailey 0-0, 7.71 | Dales 2-0, 0.00 | Foster 3 SV, 0.71 | Roper 39 G, 1.29 | Pitchford 38 G, 1.55 | Young 35 G, 1.88 | | 1886 77-64 | Roper 17-20, 3.51 | Pitchford 16-17, 3.50 | Bush 23-10, 3.11 | Livingston 13-15, 3.48 | Jones 0-2, 1.59 | Jones 2 SV, 1.59 | Roper 42 G, 3.51 | Pitchford 39 G, 3.50 | Bush 36 G, 3.11 | | 1887 61-75 | Meier 17-21, 3.35 | Roper 18-12, 2.68 | Wilkes 16-18, 3.05 | Pitchford 4-15, 5.19 | Kearns 6-5, 4.11 | Pitchford 1 SV, 5.19 | Wilkes 42 G, 3.05 | Meier 38 G, 3.35 | Roper 38 G, 2.68 | | 1888 94-43 | Meier 27-10, 1.65 | Bannister 16-17, 2.80 | Kearns 30-4, 1.01 | Brown 11-11, 2.39 | Williams 10-1, 2.75 | Kearns 8 SV, 1.01 | Kearns 57 G, 1.01 | Meier 42 G, 1.65 | Bannister 33 G, 2.80 | | 1889 83-58 | Kearns 26-12, 2.62 | Witter 21-11, 2.39 | Meier 17-12, 2.96 | Bannister 7-14, 8.57 | Dales 10-7, 3.39 | Vogel 2 SV, 2.96 | Kearns 48 G, 2.62 | Witter 46 G, 2.39 | Meier 45 G, 2.96 | | 1890 68-72 | Kearns 18-17, 2.97 | Witter 24-9, 1.86 | Ashley 12-16, 2.20 | Chadwick 7-16, 4.20 | Raynor 7-12, 4.47 | Ashley 2 SV, 2.20 | Kearns 47 G, 2.97 | Witter 46 G, 1.86 | Ashley 44 G, 2.20 | |