| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1882 0-0 | Bates 15-12, 1.64 | Brown 9-18, 3.11 | Perkins 6-16, 3.47 | Bouchard 0-1, 3.00 | Burke 2-0, 2.16 | Burke 1 SV, 2.16 | Bates 27 G, 1.64 | Brown 27 G, 3.11 | Perkins 26 G, 3.47 | | 1883 0-0 | Bonner 20-11, 2.84 | Brown 17-13, 3.09 | Keys 7-21, 3.19 | Bouchard 0-0, 0.96 | Burke 0-0, 1.12 | Bouchard 1 SV, 0.96 | Bonner 33 G, 2.84 | Brown 32 G, 3.09 | Keys 32 G, 3.19 | | 1884 0-0 | Bonner 15-17, 2.64 | Barron 11-17, 3.20 | Brown 11-16, 3.51 | Bouchard 1-0, 0.00 | Burke 0-0, 0.00 | Wagner 2 SV, 0.96 | Bonner 33 G, 2.64 | Barron 30 G, 3.20 | Brown 27 G, 3.51 | | 1885 0-0 | Robie 19-19, 2.46 | Kessler 21-14, 2.24 | Bonner 24-10, 1.86 | Bouchard 0-0, 0.00 | Browne 1-0, 2.00 | Burke 3 SV, 0.00 | Robie 39 G, 2.46 | Kessler 37 G, 2.24 | Bonner 36 G, 1.86 | | 1886 0-0 | Sawyer 31-6, 2.14 | Bonner 22-16, 3.73 | Daley 16-17, 3.68 | Forster 11-9, 4.05 | Hyman 6-4, 3.35 | Hyman 5 SV, 3.35 | Hyman 49 G, 3.35 | Sawyer 44 G, 2.14 | Bonner 38 G, 3.73 | | 1887 0-0 | Sawyer 29-9, 2.44 | Bonner 19-16, 3.49 | Daley 20-13, 2.75 | Lilly 10-13, 2.77 | Bramlett 6-4, 2.97 | Bramlett 3 SV, 2.97 | Sawyer 54 G, 2.44 | Daley 41 G, 2.75 | Bonner 39 G, 3.49 | | 1888 0-0 | Watson 25-11, 2.12 | Sawyer 22-13, 2.84 | Daley 24-8, 1.69 | Bonner 4-19, 5.76 | Dexter 5-4, 4.89 | Daley 1 SV, 1.69 | Daley 42 G, 1.69 | Sawyer 42 G, 2.84 | Watson 39 G, 2.12 | | 1889 0-0 | Watson 13-20, 3.87 | Sawyer 8-22, 4.41 | Dexter 7-22, 4.14 | Jung 10-15, 3.44 | Bonner 1-17, 8.84 | Green 1 SV, 6.64 | Jung 47 G, 3.44 | Watson 47 G, 3.87 | Sawyer 46 G, 4.41 | | 1890 0-0 | Frost 23-13, 2.09 | Dexter 24-11, 2.10 | Newell 9-19, 3.58 | Jung 19-6, 1.95 | Carlin 8-7, 3.90 | Campbell 1 SV, 3.60 | Frost 44 G, 2.09 | Dexter 43 G, 2.10 | Newell 35 G, 3.58 | | 1891 0-0 | Frost 24-23, 2.57 | Jung 20-22, 3.30 | Dexter 28-19, 2.38 | Brown 3-1, 2.70 | Campbell 0-0, 4.91 | Frost 2 SV, 2.57 | Frost 56 G, 2.57 | Dexter 47 G, 2.38 | Jung 47 G, 3.30 | | 1892 72-82 | Dexter 23-26, 3.15 | Frost 22-26, 2.80 | Jung 11-18, 3.46 | Barrell 16-12, 2.42 | Brown 0-0, 6.23 | Barrell 2 SV, 2.42 | Dexter 51 G, 3.15 | Frost 49 G, 2.80 | Barrell 38 G, 2.42 | | 1893 70-62 | Barrell 28-17, 3.74 | Dexter 25-22, 3.81 | Jung 12-15, 3.52 | Frost 5-8, 3.98 | Brown 0-0, 6.59 | Barrell 1 SV, 3.74 | Barrell 54 G, 3.74 | Dexter 47 G, 3.81 | Jung 33 G, 3.52 | |