| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1882 0-0 | Thomas 16-11, 1.73 | Martin 6-17, 5.62 | Worcester 13-13, 2.61 | Hawkins 0-0, 3.12 | Payne 1-2, 7.51 | Savage 2 SV, 2.89 | Thomas 27 G, 1.73 | Worcester 27 G, 2.61 | Martin 26 G, 5.62 | | 1883 0-0 | Bates 16-13, 3.24 | Flynn 24-9, 1.65 | Worcester 19-13, 2.74 | Martin 1-0, 1.47 | Savage 0-0, 1.50 | Weber 5 SV, 2.53 | Bates 33 G, 3.24 | Flynn 33 G, 1.65 | Worcester 32 G, 2.74 | | 1884 0-0 | Lorraine 24-6, 1.98 | OLeary 19-9, 2.83 | Bates 19-9, 2.98 | Hawkins 0-1, 7.36 | Martin 0-0, 3.52 | Savage 3 SV, 1.12 | Lorraine 32 G, 1.98 | OLeary 31 G, 2.83 | Bates 30 G, 2.98 | | 1885 0-0 | Lorraine 22-16, 2.22 | Bates 23-12, 2.36 | Marks 18-14, 2.49 | Hawkins 0-1, 6.87 | Savage 4-1, 3.32 | Savage 2 SV, 3.32 | Lorraine 39 G, 2.22 | Bates 37 G, 2.36 | Marks 35 G, 2.49 | | 1886 0-0 | Bates 14-22, 3.77 | Leggett 21-13, 2.21 | Lorraine 19-16, 3.16 | Marks 20-15, 2.54 | | Bates 0 SV, 3.77 | Leggett 44 G, 2.21 | Bates 43 G, 3.77 | Lorraine 42 G, 3.16 | | 1887 0-0 | Lorraine 30-17, 3.66 | Leggett 26-16, 2.85 | Marks 25-18, 3.77 | Grantham 3-0, 3.24 | James 0-0, 0.00 | Grantham 2 SV, 3.24 | Lorraine 48 G, 3.66 | Leggett 45 G, 2.85 | Marks 45 G, 3.77 | | 1888 0-0 | Leggett 23-15, 2.12 | Volk 25-11, 2.34 | Dales 14-17, 2.48 | Williams 10-12, 2.15 | Chandler 5-7, 3.65 | Dales 1 SV, 2.48 | Leggett 40 G, 2.12 | Williams 38 G, 2.15 | Dales 37 G, 2.48 | | 1889 85-49 | Pendleton 30-9, 1.83 | Volk 18-11, 2.88 | Daley 18-9, 2.75 | Williams 11-14, 2.65 | Leggett 8-6, 3.88 | Daley 2 SV, 2.75 | Pendleton 41 G, 1.83 | Volk 36 G, 2.88 | Daley 33 G, 2.75 | | 1890 88-52 | Daley 25-14, 2.64 | Pendleton 22-14, 2.01 | Nettleton 19-8, 2.65 | Sawyer 16-8, 2.43 | Bramlett 4-7, 4.44 | Isherwood 2 SV, 1.59 | Daley 47 G, 2.64 | Pendleton 47 G, 2.01 | Nettleton 37 G, 2.65 | |