| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1883 40-58 | Lopp 15-21, 4.14 | Riddick 15-17, 3.38 | Mercier 9-16, 4.83 | Cabiness 0-0, 9.00 | Gladstone 1-0, 2.25 | Milligan 2 SV, 8.52 | Milligan 41 G, 8.52 | Lopp 39 G, 4.14 | Riddick 34 G, 3.38 | | 1884 44-72 | Lopp 20-21, 2.57 | Anderson 15-20, 3.01 | Riddick 6-29, 5.04 | Gary 0-0, 13.50 | Gladstone 0-0, 6.75 | Milligan 1 SV, 8.74 | Lopp 42 G, 2.57 | Anderson 37 G, 3.01 | Riddick 37 G, 5.04 | | 1885 89-19 | Kirkpatrick 41-9, 2.02 | Lopp 44-9, 1.97 | Milligan 3-0, 12.38 | Smith 1-1, 6.43 | | Smith 1 SV, 6.43 | Kirkpatrick 54 G, 2.02 | Lopp 54 G, 1.97 | Smith 8 G, 6.43 | | 1886 70-56 | Kirkpatrick 21-17, 3.05 | Lopp 26-10, 3.02 | Bullock 13-18, 5.59 | Williams 10-11, 4.73 | Smith 0-0, 0.00 | Bullock 2 SV, 5.59 | Kirkpatrick 42 G, 3.05 | Lopp 41 G, 3.02 | Bullock 38 G, 5.59 | | 1887 68-59 | Kirkpatrick 17-17, 3.33 | Lopp 19-14, 3.36 | Hardy 14-15, 3.60 | Joiner 10-8, 3.25 | Bannister 4-3, 3.15 | Wall 3 SV, 2.34 | Bannister 40 G, 3.15 | Kirkpatrick 37 G, 3.33 | Lopp 36 G, 3.36 | | 1888 86-50 | Scudder 29-11, 2.00 | Wilkes 23-14, 1.86 | Hardy 21-10, 3.01 | Page 13-13, 2.75 | Lopp 0-2, 2.70 | Scudder 1 SV, 2.00 | Scudder 47 G, 2.00 | Wilkes 41 G, 1.86 | Hardy 39 G, 3.01 | | 1889 83-52 | Kirkpatrick 32-3, 2.53 | Scudder 23-10, 3.13 | Wilkes 13-15, 4.56 | Lopp 10-13, 5.22 | Trask 5-11, 5.15 | Scudder 3 SV, 3.13 | Kirkpatrick 47 G, 2.53 | Scudder 42 G, 3.13 | Wilkes 41 G, 4.56 | | 1890 75-65 | Hinz 28-13, 2.45 | Blakely 26-16, 2.51 | Lopp 8-23, 4.60 | Sheehy 13-13, 4.37 | | Hinz 1 SV, 2.45 | Hinz 49 G, 2.45 | Blakely 46 G, 2.51 | Lopp 40 G, 4.60 | | 1891 88-52 | Hinz 30-14, 2.85 | Ashford 23-19, 4.19 | Merritt 21-11, 3.00 | Graham 11-7, 4.45 | Blakely 1-1, 4.07 | Hinz 2 SV, 2.85 | Hinz 55 G, 2.85 | Ashford 46 G, 4.19 | Merritt 37 G, 3.00 | | 1892 94-60 | Hinz 30-20, 2.15 | Ashford 35-15, 2.88 | Merritt 28-22, 2.26 | Blakely 0-1, 2.92 | Graham 0-0, 18.00 | Blakely 1 SV, 2.92 | Hinz 55 G, 2.15 | Ashford 51 G, 2.88 | Merritt 51 G, 2.26 | | 1893 78-54 | Ashford 22-19, 3.58 | Hinz 29-15, 3.44 | Merritt 26-16, 3.01 | Blakely 0-0, 3.86 | Graham 1-4, 9.00 | Volk 4 SV, 2.91 | Hinz 50 G, 3.44 | Ashford 44 G, 3.58 | Merritt 44 G, 3.01 | |