| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1880 43-43 | Davis 18-12, 1.90 | Smallwood 13-11, 4.00 | Kelly 9-13, 2.52 | Earle 3-7, 2.03 | | Earle 3 SV, 2.03 | Davis 33 G, 1.90 | Kelly 29 G, 2.52 | Smallwood 27 G, 4.00 | | 1881 19-64 | Whitman 4-26, 5.55 | Schroeder 2-23, 7.40 | Davis 13-15, 3.32 | Earle 0-0, 6.75 | Gladstone 0-0, 0.00 | Davis 0 SV, 3.32 | Davis 50 G, 3.32 | Whitman 39 G, 5.55 | Schroeder 29 G, 7.40 | | 1882 22-63 | Murphy 6-21, 4.24 | Davis 7-16, 4.06 | Thayer 4-15, 5.47 | Dansby 5-11, 4.06 | Hawley 0-0, 54.00 | Dansby 1 SV, 4.06 | Dansby 38 G, 4.06 | Davis 38 G, 4.06 | Murphy 35 G, 4.24 | | 1883 15-83 | Shelton 4-25, 3.08 | Sutton 4-26, 3.10 | Murphy 1-27, 4.74 | Foster 4-1, 6.87 | McAdory 0-2, 4.50 | Foster 1 SV, 6.87 | Montague 50 G, 3.54 | Murphy 33 G, 4.74 | Shelton 33 G, 3.08 | | 1884 39-77 | Morrill 13-23, 3.11 | Sutton 13-22, 4.41 | Wallace 7-25, 3.45 | Charbonneau 0-0, 0.00 | Gibson 0-0, 3.83 | James 4 SV, 4.26 | Morrill 40 G, 3.11 | Sutton 38 G, 4.41 | Wallace 38 G, 3.45 | | 1885 67-44 | Wallace 25-14, 1.90 | Morrill 17-16, 3.47 | Rowe 19-11, 2.17 | Charbonneau 0-0, 9.00 | Coady 2-3, 1.69 | Scott 2 SV, 1.59 | Wallace 40 G, 1.90 | Morrill 37 G, 3.47 | Rowe 34 G, 2.17 | | 1886 67-58 | Wallace 23-14, 1.83 | Newell 10-24, 3.75 | Wilkes 15-11, 3.91 | Lawton 14-8, 2.43 | Douglas 0-0, 0.00 | Haskins 3 SV, 3.38 | Newell 39 G, 3.75 | Wallace 38 G, 1.83 | Wilkes 34 G, 3.91 | | 1887 70-56 | Wallace 21-16, 3.05 | Lawton 22-12, 2.91 | Ames 16-17, 2.96 | Cavanagh 9-8, 4.64 | Williams 2-3, 7.85 | Lawton 1 SV, 2.91 | Lawton 46 G, 2.91 | Ames 40 G, 2.96 | Wallace 40 G, 3.05 | | 1888 60-76 | Darlington 22-41, 3.89 | Ashford 32-32, 2.44 | Ames 3-0, 3.01 | Lawton 3-2, 1.60 | Agee 0-1, 4.50 | Ames 2 SV, 3.01 | Ashford 68 G, 2.44 | Darlington 68 G, 3.89 | Ames 36 G, 3.01 | | 1889 50-77 | Ashford 17-19, 3.73 | Lawton 14-20, 5.79 | Ames 10-18, 4.92 | Darlington 6-18, 5.52 | Blackwell 0-0, 0.00 | Pryor 4 SV, 3.94 | Ashford 48 G, 3.73 | Ames 45 G, 4.92 | Lawton 42 G, 5.79 | | 1890 76-64 | Satterfield 23-12, 2.48 | Vogel 19-16, 3.21 | Darlington 18-12, 3.26 | Blackwell 11-10, 4.13 | Craddock 5-10, 3.86 | Satterfield 3 SV, 2.48 | Satterfield 50 G, 2.48 | Vogel 46 G, 3.21 | Darlington 42 G, 3.26 | | 1891 65-75 | Darlington 18-23, 3.64 | Satterfield 23-21, 3.83 | Meier 22-23, 3.24 | Blackwell 0-0, 3.79 | Craddock 0-0, 0.00 | Sharper 2 SV, 2.60 | Meier 57 G, 3.24 | Darlington 51 G, 3.64 | Satterfield 49 G, 3.83 | | 1892 64-90 | Meier 24-27, 3.03 | Darlington 18-29, 4.24 | Satterfield 19-30, 2.84 | Craddock 1-3, 3.89 | Downs 0-0, 3.71 | Downs 3 SV, 3.71 | Meier 58 G, 3.03 | Satterfield 57 G, 2.84 | Darlington 53 G, 4.24 | | 1893 59-73 | Darlington 20-19, 3.88 | Meier 20-23, 3.91 | Satterfield 18-25, 4.98 | Craddock 0-1, 7.05 | Klein 1-2, 3.86 | Sharper 4 SV, 4.67 | Meier 49 G, 3.91 | Darlington 48 G, 3.88 | Satterfield 48 G, 4.98 | |