| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 45-35 | Rucker 24-14, 1.84 | Townsel 13-12, 2.47 | Pickett 6-8, 3.25 | Loomis 0-0, 5.40 | Randleman 0-0, 6.75 | Loomis 0 SV, 5.40 | Rucker 40 G, 1.84 | Townsel 26 G, 2.47 | Pickett 14 G, 3.25 | | 1885 39-41 | Rucker 10-15, 3.67 | Townsel 17-6, 2.05 | Stannard 2-14, 5.35 | Cabiness 0-0, 13.50 | Randleman 4-2, 5.40 | Randleman 2 SV, 5.40 | Randleman 36 G, 5.40 | Rucker 27 G, 3.67 | Townsel 27 G, 2.05 | | 1886 89-51 | Townsel 31-13, 3.31 | Marchand 19-12, 4.93 | Marshall 17-6, 4.40 | Goodwin 5-6, 4.90 | Kenyon 6-3, 4.57 | Marchand 2 SV, 4.93 | Townsel 48 G, 3.31 | Marchand 40 G, 4.93 | Marshall 30 G, 4.40 | | 1887 75-65 | Marshall 19-17, 2.88 | Townsel 21-9, 1.92 | Marchand 19-14, 2.69 | Douglas 1-2, 6.05 | Driscoll 0-0, 0.00 | Reich 19 SV, 5.13 | Reich 87 G, 5.13 | Eberhardt 84 G, 5.33 | Marshall 54 G, 2.88 | | 1888 70-70 | Marchand 23-15, 2.00 | Marshall 16-19, 2.71 | Gilman 6-7, 3.01 | Clarke 8-8, 3.21 | Bates 2-5, 3.17 | Clarke 4 SV, 3.21 | Marshall 48 G, 2.71 | Marchand 47 G, 2.00 | Reeves 46 G, 2.01 | | 1889 65-75 | Marchand 16-15, 4.31 | Marshall 11-13, 7.26 | Livingston 6-13, 11.38 | Atkins 14-8, 7.30 | Becker 4-9, 12.84 | Atkins 3 SV, 7.30 | Livingston 71 G, 11.38 | Atkins 65 G, 7.30 | Marshall 57 G, 7.26 | | 1890 60-80 | Marchand 17-16, 2.89 | Marshall 12-19, 4.38 | Livingston 14-17, 4.90 | Atkins 8-8, 4.63 | Becker 2-9, 8.57 | Haskins 1 SV, 9.89 | Marchand 51 G, 2.89 | Marshall 51 G, 4.38 | Atkins 47 G, 4.63 | |