| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1882 0-0 | Kelly 8-16, 2.70 | Poole 7-21, 3.41 | Stewart 6-15, 2.72 | Cox 3-0, 2.38 | Eberhardt 0-4, 2.12 | Eberhardt 4 SV, 2.12 | Cox 40 G, 2.38 | Kelly 29 G, 2.70 | Poole 28 G, 3.41 | | 1883 0-0 | Allerton 16-11, 3.08 | Kelly 16-16, 2.51 | Whitman 17-14, 3.37 | Eberhardt 0-1, 4.50 | Hull 0-0, 1.80 | Hull 2 SV, 1.80 | Allerton 33 G, 3.08 | Kelly 33 G, 2.51 | Whitman 32 G, 3.37 | | 1884 0-0 | Kelly 8-21, 3.84 | Allerton 6-15, 4.44 | Whitman 4-19, 4.58 | Leduc 4-4, 3.40 | Eberhardt 0-0, 0.00 | Mann 4 SV, 1.33 | Morton 35 G, 2.32 | Kelly 31 G, 3.84 | Allerton 26 G, 4.44 | | 1885 0-0 | Marshall 11-23, 2.15 | Conley 22-14, 2.28 | Leduc 9-23, 3.40 | Allerton 0-0, 0.00 | Eberhardt 1-1, 0.00 | Kelly 1 SV, 0.00 | Marshall 38 G, 2.15 | Conley 37 G, 2.28 | Leduc 33 G, 3.40 | | 1886 0-0 | Flynn 20-20, 3.38 | Conley 14-18, 3.94 | Townsend 14-18, 3.48 | Gibbs 6-16, 4.46 | Davis 3-0, 3.03 | Westcott 6 SV, 0.75 | Flynn 41 G, 3.38 | Conley 37 G, 3.94 | Branch 36 G, 3.77 | | 1887 0-0 | Flynn 24-16, 3.43 | Townsend 28-10, 2.71 | Bates 19-12, 3.53 | Clark 13-13, 3.96 | Hewitt 1-0, 1.88 | Swain 2 SV, 3.52 | Townsend 42 G, 2.71 | Flynn 41 G, 3.43 | Bates 36 G, 3.53 | | 1888 0-0 | Smith 15-25, 2.71 | Flynn 18-14, 2.04 | Townsend 19-14, 2.17 | Neal 9-6, 2.29 | Clark 3-9, 3.76 | Townsend 3 SV, 2.17 | Townsend 44 G, 2.17 | Smith 43 G, 2.71 | Flynn 32 G, 2.04 | | 1889 0-0 | Flynn 21-15, 3.35 | Benson 26-12, 2.63 | Townsend 16-13, 3.18 | Smith 10-13, 3.68 | Abrams 5-3, 4.68 | Doiley 1 SV, 2.08 | Townsend 42 G, 3.18 | Benson 39 G, 2.63 | Flynn 37 G, 3.35 | | 1890 0-0 | Heath 19-18, 2.12 | Benson 16-12, 2.61 | Flynn 14-16, 4.00 | Clements 10-17, 3.76 | Smith 6-11, 3.47 | Benson 1 SV, 2.61 | Benson 49 G, 2.61 | Heath 49 G, 2.12 | Flynn 44 G, 4.00 | | 1891 0-0 | Heath 24-24, 2.84 | Benson 20-21, 2.71 | Pfeiffer 17-10, 2.92 | Flynn 8-11, 2.55 | Silmon 2-2, 5.17 | Flynn 3 SV, 2.55 | Heath 48 G, 2.84 | Benson 46 G, 2.71 | Pfeiffer 41 G, 2.92 | | 1892 86-54 | Pfeiffer 32-17, 3.68 | Smith 25-21, 4.12 | Flynn 26-14, 5.57 | Benson 1-1, 4.41 | Clements 0-0, 3.80 | Benson 3 SV, 4.41 | Pfeiffer 56 G, 3.68 | Smith 47 G, 4.12 | Flynn 46 G, 5.57 | | 1893 57-69 | Flynn 15-22, 5.06 | Pfeiffer 15-26, 4.44 | Smith 21-14, 4.60 | Benson 1-4, 3.54 | Clements 1-0, 2.43 | Benson 3 SV, 3.54 | Pfeiffer 48 G, 4.44 | Flynn 42 G, 5.06 | Smith 42 G, 4.60 | |