| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 0-0 | Cox 23-7, 2.14 | Flynn 14-12, 2.57 | Hayden 19-9, 1.61 | Bailey 0-0, 0.00 | Evans 0-0, 2.92 | Fischer 3 SV, 1.59 | Cox 32 G, 2.14 | Flynn 29 G, 2.57 | Hayden 29 G, 1.61 | | 1885 0-0 | Cox 23-13, 1.41 | Flynn 22-14, 1.76 | Hayden 16-16, 2.09 | King 0-0, 0.00 | Roberts 2-3, 0.82 | King 2 SV, 0.00 | Cox 40 G, 1.41 | Flynn 37 G, 1.76 | Hayden 33 G, 2.09 | | 1886 0-0 | Hayden 23-17, 2.65 | King 17-24, 4.11 | Merriweather 19-14, 3.16 | Roberts 11-14, 4.18 | Bell 0-0, 0.00 | Roberts 1 SV, 4.18 | Hayden 51 G, 2.65 | King 50 G, 4.11 | Merriweather 43 G, 3.16 | | 1887 0-0 | Hayden 21-17, 3.18 | King 18-19, 3.04 | Roberts 14-16, 3.00 | Shelton 15-10, 3.25 | Merriweather 2-5, 4.83 | Bollenbach 1 SV, 4.60 | Hayden 38 G, 3.18 | King 38 G, 3.04 | Roberts 34 G, 3.00 | | 1888 0-0 | Shreve 15-19, 3.32 | Hayden 17-19, 2.47 | Marks 4-27, 6.75 | Lorraine 9-17, 2.90 | Ramsay 4-6, 4.06 | Hayden 1 SV, 2.47 | Hayden 46 G, 2.47 | Shreve 40 G, 3.32 | Marks 32 G, 6.75 | | 1889 0-0 | Staten 25-15, 3.20 | Hayden 28-10, 3.33 | Lorraine 26-11, 3.50 | Shreve 14-10, 4.30 | | Hayden 1 SV, 3.33 | Staten 52 G, 3.20 | Hayden 42 G, 3.33 | Lorraine 39 G, 3.50 | | 1890 0-0 | Staten 21-18, 3.49 | Hayden 25-12, 2.98 | Lorraine 17-17, 3.46 | Shreve 14-11, 3.45 | LeBoeuf 3-1, 1.54 | LeBoeuf 1 SV, 1.54 | Staten 43 G, 3.49 | Hayden 39 G, 2.98 | Lorraine 35 G, 3.46 | | 1891 68-72 | Hayden 22-24, 3.74 | Lorraine 25-19, 3.22 | Chastain 15-20, 4.31 | Watson 4-7, 4.17 | Bollenbach 0-0, 0.00 | Miller 2 SV, 2.40 | Hayden 48 G, 3.74 | Lorraine 47 G, 3.22 | Chastain 40 G, 4.31 | | 1892 65-89 | Hayden 23-26, 3.30 | Shreve 22-24, 2.63 | Chastain 13-31, 3.99 | Lorraine 2-7, 3.49 | Bollenbach 2-0, 3.86 | Chastain 1 SV, 3.99 | Hayden 56 G, 3.30 | Shreve 49 G, 2.63 | Chastain 47 G, 3.99 | | 1893 61-71 | Bollenbach 22-20, 4.04 | Shreve 18-22, 4.16 | Hayden 15-23, 4.87 | Chastain 5-4, 3.29 | LeBoeuf 0-1, 4.24 | Chastain 5 SV, 3.29 | Bollenbach 45 G, 4.04 | Shreve 44 G, 4.16 | Hayden 43 G, 4.87 | |