| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 32-48 | Rafferty 4-3, 2.10 | Becker 2-4, 5.27 | McDougall 4-3, 2.98 | Smith 2-1, 4.50 | | McDougall 1 SV, 2.98 | McDougall 43 G, 2.98 | Becker 34 G, 5.27 | Rafferty 8 G, 2.10 | | 1885 35-45 | Rafferty 13-14, 3.86 | McDougall 5-2, 4.30 | | | | McDougall 2 SV, 4.30 | McDougall 47 G, 4.30 | Rafferty 31 G, 3.86 | | | 1886 62-78 | Rafferty 15-28, 5.37 | Stiggers 22-21, 4.50 | Wolff 12-21, 6.14 | Allerton 2-0, 9.96 | Bouchard 0-0, 6.75 | Allerton 0 SV, 9.96 | Rafferty 47 G, 5.37 | Stiggers 47 G, 4.50 | Wolff 47 G, 6.14 | | 1887 82-58 | Rafferty 20-17, 3.50 | Stiggers 20-15, 2.96 | Wolff 12-18, 3.87 | Bouchard 10-0, 5.02 | McDougall 9-6, 4.72 | McDougall 18 SV, 4.72 | Bouchard 82 G, 5.02 | McDougall 79 G, 4.72 | Stiggers 49 G, 2.96 | | 1888 88-52 | Stiggers 30-9, 2.28 | Wolff 24-11, 2.33 | Livingston 14-12, 2.63 | Scott 9-8, 2.36 | Montague 1-3, 5.56 | Scott 25 SV, 2.36 | Scott 66 G, 2.36 | Stiggers 47 G, 2.28 | Wolff 47 G, 2.33 | | 1889 93-47 | Stiggers 34-7, 3.22 | Wolff 19-7, 6.22 | Bates 12-16, 10.96 | Cooper 0-0, 45.00 | Eberhardt 7-0, 5.86 | Stiggers 3 SV, 3.22 | Eberhardt 105 G, 5.86 | Sumlin 103 G, 7.00 | Stiggers 57 G, 3.22 | | 1890 86-54 | Stiggers 35-9, 2.15 | Wolff 23-17, 3.55 | Eberhardt 4-2, 3.39 | | | Eberhardt 5 SV, 3.39 | Eberhardt 55 G, 3.39 | Stiggers 50 G, 2.15 | Wolff 48 G, 3.55 | |