| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 41-39 | Scott 18-12, 1.54 | Lawton 15-12, 2.27 | Weston 0-1, 63.00 | | | Lawton 0 SV, 2.27 | Scott 31 G, 1.54 | Lawton 30 G, 2.27 | Weston 1 G, 63.00 | | 1885 37-43 | | | | | | | | | | | 1886 78-62 | Tuckett 20-19, 3.83 | Trask 25-16, 4.86 | Scott 7-8, 4.67 | Truitt 8-4, 3.45 | Clark 5-7, 5.29 | Blackburn 4 SV, 6.68 | Tuckett 48 G, 3.83 | Trask 47 G, 4.86 | Blackburn 40 G, 6.68 | | 1887 63-77 | Truitt 13-14, 3.12 | Tuckett 20-12, 2.28 | Beale 11-21, 4.72 | Blackburn 13-13, 4.44 | Grey 5-13, 10.19 | Blackburn 25 SV, 4.44 | Blackburn 100 G, 4.44 | Grey 84 G, 10.19 | Beale 47 G, 4.72 | | 1888 59-81 | Beale 12-24, 3.19 | Young 18-22, 3.90 | Whitman 10-10, 3.73 | Bramlett 5-11, 3.47 | Scott 0-3, 5.27 | Blackburn 7 SV, 3.41 | Blackburn 57 G, 3.41 | Beale 47 G, 3.19 | Young 46 G, 3.90 | | 1889 38-102 | Beale 12-21, 9.89 | Young 10-14, 8.07 | Gibson 1-22, 20.39 | Bramlett 6-14, 8.32 | Forster 1-15, 26.13 | Blackburn 8 SV, 7.29 | Beale 73 G, 9.89 | Blackburn 72 G, 7.29 | Gibson 64 G, 20.39 | | 1890 40-100 | Beale 8-31, 4.61 | Blackburn 4-1, 4.11 | Haviland 0-7, 16.25 | | | Blackburn 2 SV, 4.11 | Blackburn 49 G, 4.11 | Beale 48 G, 4.61 | Haviland 28 G, 16.25 | |