| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1883 | FABL | 40 | 58 | .408 | 7th | 22 | 42-56 | -2 | .269 | 4.38 | .301 | | | 42,666 | $2,084 | $9,436 | | 1884 | FABL | 44 | 72 | .379 | 7th | 31½ | 43-73 | 1 | .232 | 3.74 | .290 | | | 58,583 | $3,533 | $12,979 | | 1885 | FABL | 89 | 19 | .824 | 1st | - | 84-24 | 5 | .276 | 2.14 | .230 | | X | 132,894 | $3,451 | $34,125 | | 1886 | FABL | 70 | 56 | .556 | 3rd | 19 | 69-57 | 1 | .276 | 3.89 | .288 | | | 182,504 | $4,003 | $47,926 | | 1887 | FABL | 68 | 59 | .535 | 3rd | 21 | 70-57 | -2 | .288 | 3.34 | .260 | | | 182,863 | $4,300 | $50,441 | | 1888 | FABL | 86 | 50 | .632 | 2nd | 2 | 91-45 | -5 | .271 | 2.35 | .237 | | | 219,731 | $9,042 | $54,211 | | 1889 | FABL | 83 | 52 | .615 | 2nd | 2½ | 76-59 | 7 | .296 | 3.93 | .278 | | | 256,941 | $7,422 | $21,091 | | 1890 | FABL | 75 | 65 | .536 | 5th | 13 | 77-63 | -2 | .264 | 3.29 | .270 | | | 234,544 | $9,161 | $62,217 | | 1891 | FABL | 88 | 52 | .629 | 1st | - | 81-59 | 7 | .287 | 3.51 | .279 | | X | 213,093 | $25,991 | $6,183 | | 1892 | FABL | 94 | 60 | .610 | 3rd | 7 | 101-53 | -7 | .271 | 2.44 | .246 | | | 224,692 | $8,517 | $27,774 | | 1893 | FABL | 78 | 54 | .591 | 3rd | 5 | 74-58 | 4 | .287 | 3.41 | .282 | | | 239,804 | $8,189 | $30,475 | |
