| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1876 | FABL | 43 | 17 | .717 | 1st | - | 43-17 | 0 | .327 | 2.50 | .269 | | X | 44,381 | $990 | $12,969 | | 1877 | FABL | 23 | 37 | .383 | 5th | 17 | 26-34 | -3 | .260 | 3.88 | .301 | | | 36,196 | $1,483 | $9,260 | | 1878 | FABL | 31 | 31 | .500 | 3rd | 17½ | 29-33 | 2 | .283 | 3.32 | .293 | | | 43,854 | $2,592 | $7,237 | | 1879 | FABL | 41 | 36 | .532 | 3rd | 17 | 38-39 | 3 | .249 | 3.33 | .302 | | | 60,797 | $3,228 | $9,456 | | 1880 | FABL | 59 | 26 | .694 | 1st | - | 63-22 | -4 | .263 | 1.81 | .249 | | X | 65,912 | $2,783 | $13,446 | | 1881 | FABL | 50 | 35 | .588 | 3rd | 4 | 48-37 | 2 | .287 | 3.41 | .288 | | | 67,322 | $3,584 | $12,751 | | 1882 | FABL | 61 | 24 | .718 | 1st | - | 60-25 | 1 | .306 | 3.09 | .284 | | X | 65,724 | $4,129 | $12,017 | | 1883 | FABL | 50 | 49 | .505 | 6th | 12½ | 51-48 | -1 | .276 | 3.59 | .304 | | | 78,407 | $2,282 | $15,643 | | 1884 | FABL | 59 | 54 | .522 | 4th | 15 | 64-49 | -5 | .284 | 3.09 | .286 | | | 202,452 | $3,245 | $42,645 | | 1885 | FABL | 45 | 67 | .402 | 6th | 46 | 44-68 | 1 | .248 | 3.05 | .284 | | | 186,329 | $3,892 | $40,974 | | 1886 | FABL | 79 | 47 | .627 | 2nd | 10 | 81-45 | -2 | .281 | 2.59 | .271 | | | 262,891 | $3,908 | $57,812 | | 1887 | FABL | 68 | 61 | .527 | 4th | 22 | 67-62 | 1 | .267 | 3.61 | .298 | | | 236,116 | $3,647 | $55,817 | | 1888 | FABL | 67 | 71 | .486 | 4th | 22 | 71-67 | -4 | .261 | 2.88 | .280 | | | 236,636 | $9,078 | $48,597 | | 1889 | FABL | 63 | 68 | .481 | 5th | 20½ | 67-64 | -4 | .280 | 3.91 | .312 | | | 243,030 | $9,554 | $21,105 | | 1890 | FABL | 77 | 63 | .550 | 3rd | 11 | 79-61 | -2 | .269 | 3.07 | .276 | | | 276,112 | $9,402 | $62,092 | |
