| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | WF | 51 | 29 | .638 | 1st | - | 50-30 | 1 | .252 | 2.18 | .233 | | X | 59,070 | $0 | $0 | | 1885 | FABL | 50 | 61 | .450 | 5th | 40½ | 49-62 | 1 | .237 | 3.26 | .258 | | | 89,534 | $5,120 | -$3,025 | | 1886 | FABL | 60 | 66 | .476 | 5th | 29 | 63-63 | -3 | .247 | 3.03 | .253 | | | 110,427 | $3,304 | -$1,130 | | 1887 | WF | 53 | 87 | .379 | 6th | 29 | 49-91 | 4 | .279 | 6.40 | .336 | | | 106,266 | $3,304 | -$1,130 | | 1888 | WF | 69 | 71 | .493 | 4th | 19 | 68-72 | 1 | .226 | 2.34 | .247 | | | 69,304 | $3,304 | -$1,130 | | 1889 | WF | 47 | 93 | .336 | 5th | 47 | 54-86 | -7 | .257 | 11.02 | .320 | | | 69,150 | $3,304 | -$1,130 | | 1890 | WF | 60 | 80 | .429 | 4th | 28 | 62-78 | -2 | .249 | 4.43 | .296 | | | 91,284 | $3,304 | -$1,130 | |
