| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1876 | FABL | 47 | 23 | .671 | 3rd | 1 | 47-23 | 0 | .273 | 2.29 | .262 | | | 47,976 | $1,000 | $14,982 | | 1877 | FABL | 31 | 29 | .517 | 4th | 9 | 33-27 | -2 | .299 | 3.37 | .300 | | | 39,946 | $1,452 | $12,985 | | 1878 | FABL | 20 | 40 | .333 | 5th | 27½ | 22-38 | -2 | .250 | 3.04 | .311 | | | 37,255 | $2,160 | $8,984 | | 1879 | FABL | 41 | 43 | .488 | 4th | 20½ | 40-44 | 1 | .254 | 2.91 | .283 | | | 62,316 | $2,692 | $10,272 | | 1880 | FABL | 33 | 52 | .388 | 7th | 26 | 31-54 | 2 | .211 | 3.12 | .287 | | | 64,579 | $1,980 | $13,646 | | 1881 | FABL | 45 | 38 | .542 | 4th | 8 | 43-40 | 2 | .283 | 3.05 | .277 | | | 68,083 | $2,643 | $14,361 | | 1882 | FABL | 44 | 40 | .524 | 4th | 16½ | 43-41 | 1 | .255 | 3.04 | .288 | | | 63,273 | $3,609 | $12,986 | | 1883 | FABL | 62 | 36 | .633 | 1st | - | 61-37 | 1 | .265 | 2.70 | .271 | | X | 81,584 | $2,582 | $16,203 | | 1884 | FABL | 75 | 40 | .652 | 1st | - | 77-38 | -2 | .262 | 2.51 | .261 | | X | 96,780 | $2,660 | $20,319 | | 1885 | FABL | 40 | 73 | .354 | 7th | 51½ | 44-69 | -4 | .238 | 3.72 | .290 | | | 98,279 | $4,223 | $21,333 | |
