| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1876 46-20 | Miller 21-11, 1.98 | Murphy 24-9, 1.46 | Pinkerton 1-0, 1.93 | | | Miller 0 SV, 1.98 | Miller 34 G, 1.98 | Murphy 33 G, 1.46 | Pinkerton 1 G, 1.93 | | 1877 19-41 | Ryan 19-41, 3.85 | Bullock 0-0, 3.97 | Gregory 0-0, 9.06 | | | Gregory 1 SV, 9.06 | Ryan 60 G, 3.85 | Gregory 25 G, 9.06 | Bullock 7 G, 3.97 | | 1878 48-13 | Scott 25-8, 1.23 | Cannon 23-5, 1.57 | | | | Cannon 0 SV, 1.57 | Scott 33 G, 1.23 | Cannon 28 G, 1.57 | | | 1879 59-20 | Lockhart 28-13, 2.15 | Roberson 31-7, 1.39 | Bryant 0-0, 6.75 | | | Bryant 0 SV, 6.75 | Lockhart 41 G, 2.15 | Roberson 40 G, 1.39 | Bryant 1 G, 6.75 | | 1880 43-43 | Roberson 15-14, 2.10 | Lockhart 18-10, 2.46 | Page 10-18, 3.09 | Thomas 0-1, 3.29 | | Lockhart 0 SV, 2.46 | Roberson 30 G, 2.10 | Lockhart 29 G, 2.46 | Page 28 G, 3.09 | | 1881 40-44 | Lockhart 11-19, 2.80 | Manuel 20-10, 1.92 | Gibbons 9-15, 2.78 | Work 0-0, 0.00 | | Gibbons 1 SV, 2.78 | Manuel 33 G, 1.92 | Lockhart 32 G, 2.80 | Gibbons 29 G, 2.78 | | 1882 36-48 | Manuel 10-16, 3.21 | Moody 7-16, 3.31 | Lockhart 14-7, 2.46 | Sheehan 5-9, 3.49 | | Lockhart 1 SV, 2.46 | Lockhart 38 G, 2.46 | Moody 30 G, 3.31 | Manuel 29 G, 3.21 | | 1883 57-41 | Sheehan 18-13, 2.38 | Young 19-12, 2.10 | Lockhart 15-14, 3.26 | Bauer 5-2, 2.14 | | Bauer 2 SV, 2.14 | Sheehan 34 G, 2.38 | Young 34 G, 2.10 | Lockhart 32 G, 3.26 | | 1884 56-57 | Clark 17-15, 2.83 | Lockhart 19-16, 2.84 | Bauer 15-19, 4.61 | Forster 1-2, 5.59 | Kinney 2-1, 4.76 | McAdory 3 SV, 3.67 | Clark 39 G, 2.83 | Bauer 38 G, 4.61 | Lockhart 38 G, 2.84 | | 1885 32-81 | Clark 10-26, 4.26 | Crosby 10-24, 3.65 | Lockhart 9-24, 4.39 | Bauer 0-0, 1.73 | Favors 0-0, 5.20 | Stiggers 3 SV, 3.09 | Clark 38 G, 4.26 | Crosby 38 G, 3.65 | Lockhart 37 G, 4.39 | |