| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1876 | FABL | 46 | 20 | .697 | 2nd | - | 48-18 | -2 | .275 | 1.72 | .236 | | | 51,400 | $998 | $15,616 | | 1877 | FABL | 19 | 41 | .317 | 6th | 21 | 17-43 | 2 | .254 | 4.39 | .315 | | | 35,445 | $1,294 | $7,981 | | 1878 | FABL | 48 | 13 | .787 | 1st | - | 49-12 | -1 | .300 | 1.39 | .253 | | X | 63,012 | $1,952 | $11,528 | | 1879 | FABL | 59 | 20 | .747 | 1st | - | 55-24 | 4 | .263 | 1.79 | .243 | | X | 78,120 | $1,884 | $14,540 | | 1880 | FABL | 43 | 43 | .500 | 5th | 16½ | 43-43 | 0 | .251 | 2.56 | .250 | | | 79,227 | $3,806 | $15,351 | | 1881 | FABL | 40 | 44 | .476 | 6th | 13½ | 40-44 | 0 | .258 | 2.48 | .265 | | | 80,332 | $2,736 | $16,934 | | 1882 | FABL | 36 | 48 | .429 | 6th | 24½ | 40-44 | -4 | .244 | 3.08 | .261 | | | 85,824 | $3,255 | $16,882 | | 1883 | FABL | 57 | 41 | .582 | 3rd | 5 | 59-39 | -2 | .279 | 2.53 | .271 | | | 101,031 | $2,718 | $20,271 | | 1884 | FABL | 56 | 57 | .496 | 5th | 18 | 57-56 | -1 | .286 | 3.51 | .282 | | | 116,508 | $3,082 | $24,480 | | 1885 | FABL | 32 | 81 | .283 | 8th | 59½ | 37-76 | -5 | .240 | 4.06 | .307 | | | 102,338 | $5,642 | $22,137 | |
