| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1882 0-0 | Keys 15-9, 2.45 | McGuire 15-10, 1.81 | Stamps 14-11, 2.46 | Batiste 0-0, 0.00 | Burton 1-0, 1.31 | Batiste 1 SV, 0.00 | Keys 25 G, 2.45 | McGuire 25 G, 1.81 | Stamps 25 G, 2.46 | | 1883 0-0 | Rucker 18-12, 2.84 | McGuire 16-12, 2.82 | Thomas 14-15, 3.07 | Batiste 0-0, 2.81 | Bowens 2-1, 2.15 | Batiste 4 SV, 2.81 | Rucker 33 G, 2.84 | McGuire 32 G, 2.82 | Thomas 32 G, 3.07 | | 1884 0-0 | Montague 8-19, 4.41 | Okereke 6-22, 4.58 | Beale 13-14, 2.77 | Batiste 1-4, 4.24 | Browne 1-1, 1.62 | Batiste 3 SV, 4.24 | Montague 31 G, 4.41 | Okereke 31 G, 4.58 | Beale 28 G, 2.77 | | 1885 0-0 | McDonough 14-18, 2.76 | Beale 10-20, 3.46 | Dansby 11-17, 2.46 | Okereke 2-15, 4.49 | Batiste 1-0, 2.70 | Fischer 1 SV, 2.81 | McDonough 34 G, 2.76 | Beale 32 G, 3.46 | Dansby 30 G, 2.46 | | 1886 0-0 | McDonough 28-10, 2.31 | Pfeiffer 25-10, 2.24 | Watton 14-18, 5.59 | Lockhart 17-9, 3.52 | Caswell 0-0, 27.00 | Ferguson 3 SV, 5.30 | McDonough 48 G, 2.31 | Watton 41 G, 5.59 | Pfeiffer 40 G, 2.24 | | 1887 63-65 | Cannon 19-19, 4.11 | McDonough 21-21, 4.25 | Lockhart 19-21, 3.81 | Ferguson 4-4, 4.30 | Reardon 0-0, 0.00 | Ferguson 1 SV, 4.30 | Lockhart 50 G, 3.81 | McDonough 48 G, 4.25 | Cannon 47 G, 4.11 | | 1888 57-74 | McDonough 20-39, 3.18 | Shelton 19-24, 3.27 | Merritt 13-10, 2.23 | Lockhart 3-1, 1.91 | McElroy 2-0, 0.00 | Lockhart 1 SV, 1.91 | McDonough 64 G, 3.18 | Shelton 53 G, 3.27 | Merritt 39 G, 2.23 | | 1889 58-72 | Merritt 13-15, 4.07 | McDonough 14-15, 3.74 | Parker 7-15, 6.00 | Lockhart 12-10, 4.25 | Abernathy 9-11, 5.05 | Merritt 4 SV, 4.07 | Merritt 55 G, 4.07 | McDonough 51 G, 3.74 | Lockhart 48 G, 4.25 | | 1890 28-112 | Ellsworth 8-28, 3.80 | Toole 6-19, 4.87 | Morse 4-22, 4.43 | Galloway 4-19, 6.92 | Kraemer 4-16, 5.52 | Ellsworth 2 SV, 3.80 | Toole 59 G, 4.87 | Ellsworth 57 G, 3.80 | Galloway 47 G, 6.92 | |