| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1879 34-47 | Tucker 16-10, 1.45 | Fallow 5-16, 3.10 | Bryant 7-10, 2.37 | Taylor 4-4, 2.18 | Dunn 0-0, 0.00 | Mathews 2 SV, 2.28 | Mathews 30 G, 2.28 | Tucker 26 G, 1.45 | Fallow 25 G, 3.10 | | 1880 47-38 | Kirkpatrick 20-9, 1.10 | Lopp 12-14, 3.25 | Ryan 13-14, 2.66 | Dansby 2-1, 1.16 | | Kirkpatrick 2 SV, 1.10 | Kirkpatrick 32 G, 1.10 | Ryan 29 G, 2.66 | Lopp 28 G, 3.25 | | 1881 38-46 | Kirkpatrick 14-15, 2.54 | Lopp 15-13, 2.29 | Cook 9-18, 3.15 | | | Lopp 1 SV, 2.29 | Kirkpatrick 35 G, 2.54 | Lopp 31 G, 2.29 | Cook 28 G, 3.15 | | 1882 38-48 | Kirkpatrick 17-11, 3.34 | Lopp 11-19, 4.05 | Trease 10-18, 3.31 | Buckingham 0-0, 0.00 | Kildare 0-0, 7.45 | Kirkpatrick 1 SV, 3.34 | Kirkpatrick 49 G, 3.34 | Lopp 36 G, 4.05 | Trease 32 G, 3.31 | |