| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1890 0-0 | Rucker 15-22, 4.04 | Thistlethwaite 21-15, 2.51 | Milner 16-16, 4.11 | Wilkes 11-17, 3.85 | Benton 3-1, 3.88 | Benton 1 SV, 3.88 | Rucker 47 G, 4.04 | Thistlethwaite 45 G, 2.51 | Milner 37 G, 4.11 | | 1891 0-0 | Leggett 20-25, 2.56 | Milner 19-18, 2.97 | Quigley 5-19, 3.56 | Rucker 4-12, 3.41 | Thistlethwaite 4-8, 4.39 | Thistlethwaite 2 SV, 4.39 | Leggett 47 G, 2.56 | Milner 45 G, 2.97 | Thistlethwaite 29 G, 4.39 | | 1892 59-95 | Heath 20-32, 2.79 | Leggett 20-29, 3.11 | Milner 18-31, 2.85 | Rucker 0-3, 3.71 | Aker 1-0, 1.65 | Wilder 3 SV, 2.16 | Heath 53 G, 2.79 | Leggett 52 G, 3.11 | Milner 51 G, 2.85 | | 1893 60-72 | Heath 21-20, 3.49 | Leggett 19-22, 3.65 | Milner 15-17, 3.73 | Beaumont 4-4, 3.82 | Gauthier 1-2, 11.70 | Wilder 6 SV, 2.80 | Leggett 48 G, 3.65 | Heath 44 G, 3.49 | Milner 41 G, 3.73 | |