| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1887 52-74 | Anthony 16-20, 3.01 | Flowers 12-17, 3.88 | Harewood 12-17, 4.52 | Wilder 7-8, 3.47 | Adams 1-2, 5.03 | Sewell 5 SV, 6.75 | Sewell 47 G, 6.75 | Flowers 37 G, 3.88 | Anthony 36 G, 3.01 | | 1888 57-80 | Anthony 20-23, 2.82 | Flowers 20-25, 3.24 | Hobbs 14-27, 4.41 | Carter 1-0, 2.82 | DeVault 0-0, 16.20 | Sewell 4 SV, 3.24 | Flowers 47 G, 3.24 | Anthony 46 G, 2.82 | Hobbs 45 G, 4.41 | | 1889 68-65 | Schneider 14-23, 3.69 | Anthony 14-15, 4.01 | Hinz 17-13, 3.68 | Hobbs 13-6, 3.76 | Chadwick 9-7, 4.72 | Hinz 2 SV, 3.68 | Schneider 43 G, 3.69 | Hinz 42 G, 3.68 | Anthony 41 G, 4.01 | | 1890 72-68 | Dalrymple 20-14, 3.04 | Lawton 12-18, 3.48 | Cleveland 12-14, 4.11 | Parsons 17-10, 3.83 | Selfridge 9-9, 5.03 | Lawton 5 SV, 3.48 | Dalrymple 51 G, 3.04 | Lawton 51 G, 3.48 | Cleveland 49 G, 4.11 | | 1891 50-90 | Cleveland 16-30, 4.48 | Dalrymple 11-33, 4.39 | Parsons 11-13, 4.07 | Lawton 6-10, 3.84 | Browne 5-1, 3.55 | Browne 4 SV, 3.55 | Cleveland 57 G, 4.48 | Dalrymple 49 G, 4.39 | Parsons 35 G, 4.07 | | 1892 63-91 | Dalrymple 17-31, 4.13 | Callahan 12-19, 3.80 | Cleveland 17-16, 3.50 | McCann 10-16, 3.24 | Parsons 0-2, 2.35 | Wofford 3 SV, 1.89 | Dalrymple 52 G, 4.13 | Cleveland 38 G, 3.50 | Callahan 37 G, 3.80 | | 1893 63-69 | Blackwell 18-24, 4.38 | Dalrymple 22-17, 3.97 | Ryan 15-20, 4.58 | McCann 3-4, 3.49 | Cleveland 2-3, 2.17 | Cleveland 1 SV, 2.17 | Blackwell 54 G, 4.38 | Dalrymple 48 G, 3.97 | Ryan 39 G, 4.58 | | 1894 65-67 | Blackwell 30-17, 3.80 | Ryan 14-19, 5.14 | Cleveland 12-15, 4.96 | McCann 2-1, 6.58 | Dalrymple 0-6, 5.68 | Reeves 3 SV, 8.44 | Blackwell 59 G, 3.80 | Cleveland 37 G, 4.96 | Ryan 37 G, 5.14 | | 1895 70-62 | Blackwell 29-17, 4.51 | McCann 11-13, 5.31 | Cleveland 10-10, 5.29 | Ryan 5-8, 4.47 | Lawton 5-7, 5.21 | Blackwell 3 SV, 4.51 | Blackwell 55 G, 4.51 | McCann 38 G, 5.31 | Cleveland 27 G, 5.29 | | 1896 63-69 | Blackwell 22-19, 3.26 | Weiss 21-25, 4.22 | Babcock 8-10, 5.06 | Ryan 5-6, 4.38 | Tuckett 3-3, 3.63 | Weiss 3 SV, 4.22 | Weiss 57 G, 4.22 | Blackwell 44 G, 3.26 | Babcock 22 G, 5.06 | | 1897 68-64 | Blackwell 20-23, 3.70 | Babcock 22-12, 3.74 | Weiss 11-16, 4.84 | McCann 13-7, 3.36 | Cleveland 0-2, 6.75 | Blackwell 1 SV, 3.70 | Blackwell 50 G, 3.70 | Babcock 42 G, 3.74 | Weiss 32 G, 4.84 | | 1898 70-84 | Weiss 25-26, 3.01 | Babcock 18-26, 3.14 | Blackwell 13-12, 2.82 | McCann 8-16, 3.86 | Wadsworth 3-4, 3.94 | Wadsworth 1 SV, 3.94 | Weiss 59 G, 3.01 | Babcock 53 G, 3.14 | McCann 38 G, 3.86 | | 1899 79-75 | Weiss 25-18, 2.86 | McCann 26-18, 3.93 | Wadsworth 19-28, 3.87 | Babcock 5-4, 2.27 | Clarke 3-4, 3.72 | Babcock 5 SV, 2.27 | Weiss 59 G, 2.86 | Wadsworth 57 G, 3.87 | McCann 55 G, 3.93 | |