| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1881 49-34 | Allerton 16-11, 3.72 | Page 17-9, 3.47 | Fallow 12-10, 3.05 | Coleman 3-2, 4.50 | Dansby 1-2, 1.29 | Dansby 2 SV, 1.29 | Allerton 33 G, 3.72 | Page 27 G, 3.47 | Fallow 24 G, 3.05 | | 1882 31-53 | Penick 10-14, 2.85 | Smallwood 8-15, 4.02 | Sidberry 2-14, 6.27 | Page 11-10, 2.84 | Harmon 0-0, 0.00 | Page 3 SV, 2.84 | Page 41 G, 2.84 | Penick 34 G, 2.85 | Sidberry 24 G, 6.27 | | 1883 50-48 | Page 19-14, 2.34 | Crutchfield 20-11, 1.55 | Thomas 8-18, 4.77 | Endicott 1-4, 5.66 | Means 0-1, 3.55 | Crutchfield 0 SV, 1.55 | Page 34 G, 2.34 | Crutchfield 33 G, 1.55 | Thomas 31 G, 4.77 | | 1884 65-49 | Crutchfield 30-9, 1.97 | Schneider 15-22, 3.47 | Page 19-15, 3.52 | Endicott 1-3, 2.35 | Jackson 0-0, 7.84 | Endicott 4 SV, 2.35 | Crutchfield 40 G, 1.97 | Schneider 38 G, 3.47 | Page 36 G, 3.52 | | 1885 62-49 | Page 17-17, 2.45 | Schneider 16-16, 3.18 | LeBoeuf 20-14, 2.18 | Endicott 8-1, 1.82 | Jackson 1-1, 2.73 | Endicott 1 SV, 1.82 | Page 39 G, 2.45 | Schneider 37 G, 3.18 | LeBoeuf 35 G, 2.18 | | 1886 88-36 | LeBoeuf 30-6, 1.88 | Schneider 29-6, 2.20 | Vogel 14-12, 3.37 | Schultz 13-8, 2.92 | Hennington 2-4, 2.38 | Hennington 4 SV, 2.38 | LeBoeuf 38 G, 1.88 | Schneider 36 G, 2.20 | Vogel 32 G, 3.37 | | 1887 88-37 | LeBoeuf 25-9, 3.69 | Schneider 22-12, 3.09 | Page 20-8, 2.28 | Parker 16-7, 3.20 | Beal 3-1, 2.79 | Page 1 SV, 2.28 | LeBoeuf 38 G, 3.69 | Schneider 38 G, 3.09 | Page 31 G, 2.28 | | 1888 89-49 | Beal 36-25, 3.01 | Schneider 43-22, 1.88 | LeBoeuf 4-2, 3.58 | Carmichael 6-0, 1.02 | Parker 0-0, 0.00 | LeBoeuf 1 SV, 3.58 | Beal 66 G, 3.01 | Schneider 66 G, 1.88 | LeBoeuf 21 G, 3.58 | |