1961 AFA Season Recap: "Stars Shine Bright Again"
AFA Expands and Adapts
The American Football Association expanded to 14 teams in 1961, introducing the Buffalo Red Jackets and Houston Drillers. The league also increased its schedule to 14 games, making for an action-packed season. Predictably, the new teams struggled, each finishing 3-11. Buffalo showed flashes of promise, with quarterback Jim Rizzi and rookie linebacker Gary Scruggs earning All-Pro honors. Houston, anchored by Defensive Rookie of the Year Jim Griffin, also laid some defensive groundwork for the future.
East Division: New York’s Reign Continues
The New York Stars solidified their dominance, finishing 13-1 behind MVP quarterback Orlin Youngs, who threw for over 2,500 yards. Rookie Reid McDuffy stepped into the halfback role vacated by retired star Larry Moen, rushing for 949 yards and earning Offensive Rookie of the Year honors. After a Week 2 loss to Pittsburgh, the Stars won 12 straight games, leading the league in scoring and allowing the fewest points.
The Washington Wasps rebounded from a disappointing 1960 campaign to claim the second playoff spot with a 9-5 record. Quarterback Robin Hornick and veteran end Jim Edmonds led the offense. Washington edged out the Pittsburgh Paladins, who also finished 9-5, for the postseason on a head-to-head tiebreaker.
Cleveland (7-7) saw another standout season from halfback Erskine Rizzuto (1,300+ rushing yards), while Philadelphia (6-8) enjoyed strong performances from quarterback Jack Osterman, who led the league with 2,780 passing yards, and Boston (6-8) continued its middling ways. Buffalo, despite its record, upset Washington twice and showcased rising talents.
West Division: Detroit Surges, Chicago Strikes
The Detroit Maroons rebounded from a humiliating 1960 playoff loss with a 12-2 season. Halfback Art Heal led the league with 1,627 rushing yards, while rookie quarterback Dee Cann guided an offense that scored a league-best 411 points. The Maroons clinched the division early but faltered in the postseason.
The Chicago Wildcats secured second place at 8-6, propelled by their defense and fullback George Hornback’s timely touchdowns. The Los Angeles Tigers (7-7) boasted a high-powered offense led by quarterback Garton Bird and halfback Dick Drum, but defensive woes kept them out of contention.
Kansas City (6-8) struggled after handing the quarterback reins to rookie Pete Fairfield, despite a strong rushing attack. St. Louis (5-9) and San Francisco (4-10) had down years, while Houston (3-11) showcased potential on defense with standout rookies Griffin and John Padgett.
Playoffs: Stars Dominate, Maroons Collapse
East Division Playoff: The New York Stars steamrolled Washington 34-3. Orlin Youngs threw two touchdown passes, and McDuffy added 102 rushing yards as the Stars’ defense stifled the Wasps’ offense, allowing just 198 total yards.
West Division Playoff: For the second straight year, the Detroit Maroons collapsed in the playoffs, losing 30-7 to Chicago. Turnovers and a smothering Wildcats defense spelled doom for Detroit. Hornback scored three touchdowns, and the Maroons’ star Art Heal was held to just two yards per carry.
AFA Title Game: New York Stars 24, Chicago Wildcats 20
In a clash of AFA titans, New York overcame an early 10-0 deficit to defeat Chicago and claim back-to-back championships. The game turned late in the second quarter when New York scored twice in 24 seconds, thanks to a fumble recovery and a Reid McDuffy touchdown.
Defensive stalwart Galen Cossey forced two key turnovers, while Orlin Youngs added a third-quarter touchdown pass to extend the lead. Chicago mounted a late rally, but the Stars’ defense held firm to secure their fourth title in 10 years.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
1961 AFA Most Valuable Player Orlin Youngs, NY Stars |
1961 AFA Offensive Player of the Year Art Heal, Detroit Maroons |
1961 AFA Defensive Player of the Year Jerry Grover, NY Stars |
 |
 |
 |