| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 50-48 | Mulligan 21-21, 2.35 | Keys 18-14, 3.13 | Sherrod 8-7, 2.74 | Cavanagh 0-0, 0.53 | Favors 1-0, 0.00 | Cavanagh 1 SV, 0.53 | Mulligan 45 G, 2.35 | Keys 35 G, 3.13 | Sherrod 19 G, 2.74 | | 1885 63-35 | Keys 20-11, 3.35 | Mulligan 21-9, 2.43 | Sherrod 12-12, 3.60 | Axel 0-0, 0.00 | Cavanagh 4-2, 2.71 | Cavanagh 2 SV, 2.71 | Cavanagh 36 G, 2.71 | Mulligan 36 G, 2.43 | Keys 34 G, 3.35 | | 1886 83-57 | Mulligan 32-11, 4.28 | Thomas 23-17, 6.13 | Scott 6-10, 7.28 | Crosby 7-9, 6.16 | Trease 2-3, 2.95 | Cavanagh 1 SV, 2.29 | Mulligan 47 G, 4.28 | Thomas 46 G, 6.13 | Kiernan 25 G, 4.64 | | 1887 59-79 | Mulligan 28-15, 3.21 | Scott 10-32, 5.75 | Thomas 14-29, 4.90 | Cox 0-1, 13.50 | Hannah 4-0, 1.37 | Hannah 4 SV, 1.37 | Mulligan 46 G, 3.21 | Scott 46 G, 5.75 | Thomas 46 G, 4.90 | | 1888 70-70 | Townsel 26-19, 2.40 | Truitt 25-13, 2.11 | Murdock 12-31, 3.04 | Hannah 4-3, 1.63 | Sherrod 0-0, 0.00 | Hannah 4 SV, 1.63 | Townsel 47 G, 2.40 | Truitt 47 G, 2.11 | Murdock 46 G, 3.04 | | 1889 84-53 | Townsel 35-15, 1.95 | Truitt 21-15, 2.37 | Murdock 19-10, 2.58 | Pitchford 4-6, 2.97 | Thomas 1-0, 2.63 | Thomas 1 SV, 2.63 | Townsel 57 G, 1.95 | Truitt 46 G, 2.37 | Murdock 37 G, 2.58 | | 1890 81-59 | Townsel 29-19, 2.12 | Truitt 19-10, 3.48 | Murdock 16-14, 3.86 | Pitchford 5-7, 2.97 | Thomas 2-1, 4.50 | Murdock 2 SV, 3.86 | Townsel 57 G, 2.12 | Truitt 50 G, 3.48 | Murdock 45 G, 3.86 | |