| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 46-52 | Holmes 22-22, 2.49 | Carter 13-20, 2.81 | | | | Carter 0 SV, 2.81 | Holmes 47 G, 2.49 | Carter 36 G, 2.81 | | | 1885 43-53 | Holmes 25-20, 3.02 | Carter 12-16, 3.65 | Bryan 0-0, 3.86 | | | Bryan 1 SV, 3.86 | Holmes 45 G, 3.02 | Carter 35 G, 3.65 | Bryan 2 G, 3.86 | | 1886 53-87 | Holmes 14-28, 5.42 | Pickett 20-21, 4.48 | Noyes 11-24, 6.36 | Hull 3-3, 6.79 | Bailey 1-2, 4.85 | Atwood 1 SV, 6.07 | Holmes 47 G, 5.42 | Pickett 44 G, 4.48 | Noyes 37 G, 6.36 | | 1887 60-81 | Browne 17-28, 4.57 | Holmes 20-23, 3.80 | Pickett 20-23, 3.99 | Atwood 2-2, 2.25 | Bailey 0-2, 2.77 | Atwood 0 SV, 2.25 | Browne 47 G, 4.57 | Holmes 47 G, 3.80 | Pickett 47 G, 3.99 | | 1888 48-92 | Holmes 18-27, 2.85 | Pickett 15-31, 3.44 | Browne 10-32, 4.26 | Agee 0-0, 0.00 | Allerton 0-0, 2.08 | Atwood 3 SV, 2.82 | Holmes 47 G, 2.85 | Pickett 47 G, 3.44 | Browne 46 G, 4.26 | | 1889 59-78 | Pickett 20-25, 2.23 | Holmes 19-24, 2.67 | Browne 10-19, 3.23 | Gibbs 8-6, 0.97 | Hull 1-4, 3.21 | Hull 3 SV, 3.21 | Pickett 57 G, 2.23 | Holmes 47 G, 2.67 | Browne 37 G, 3.23 | | 1890 63-77 | Pickett 14-31, 3.54 | Holmes 22-19, 2.93 | Gibbs 17-12, 2.90 | Hull 9-11, 3.75 | Agee 1-2, 3.73 | Agee 3 SV, 3.73 | Pickett 57 G, 3.54 | Holmes 50 G, 2.93 | Gibbs 43 G, 2.90 | |