| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 47-51 | Kraus 20-25, 2.72 | Mahoney 15-17, 2.85 | Lilly 12-9, 2.32 | Agee 0-0, 3.00 | Atwood 0-0, 0.00 | Agee 0 SV, 3.00 | Kraus 45 G, 2.72 | Mahoney 33 G, 2.85 | Lilly 21 G, 2.32 | | 1885 56-42 | Kraus 21-10, 3.11 | Mahoney 21-10, 3.81 | Lilly 12-18, 3.51 | Atwood 0-0, 2.25 | Easterling 0-0, 15.26 | Atwood 0 SV, 2.25 | Kraus 33 G, 3.11 | Mahoney 33 G, 3.81 | Lilly 32 G, 3.51 | | 1886 75-65 | Kraus 32-14, 3.54 | Mahoney 16-28, 5.34 | Lilly 24-20, 4.32 | Lenox 0-0, 10.80 | Montague 0-0, 4.05 | Wagner 3 SV, 7.56 | Kraus 47 G, 3.54 | Mahoney 47 G, 5.34 | Lilly 46 G, 4.32 | | 1887 81-57 | Kraus 28-16, 2.86 | Mahoney 26-17, 3.66 | Montague 21-22, 3.90 | Morton 3-0, 5.95 | Wagner 1-1, 1.88 | Wagner 4 SV, 1.88 | Kraus 46 G, 2.86 | Mahoney 46 G, 3.66 | Montague 46 G, 3.90 | | 1888 58-82 | Kraus 16-30, 3.35 | Cathey 26-16, 1.85 | Mahoney 15-28, 3.64 | Montague 0-1, 2.08 | Reich 0-3, 5.79 | Reich 1 SV, 5.79 | Kraus 48 G, 3.35 | Cathey 46 G, 1.85 | Mahoney 46 G, 3.64 | | 1889 61-78 | Cathey 25-22, 1.80 | Mahoney 19-24, 2.97 | Kraus 14-19, 2.48 | Gilman 3-10, 2.94 | Butler 0-2, 5.26 | Mahoney 2 SV, 2.97 | Cathey 57 G, 1.80 | Mahoney 52 G, 2.97 | Kraus 41 G, 2.48 | | 1890 38-102 | Mahoney 8-25, 4.53 | Kraus 7-26, 4.51 | Gilman 5-10, 4.27 | Butler 3-6, 5.07 | Reich 2-3, 2.96 | Gilman 3 SV, 4.27 | Mahoney 61 G, 4.53 | Kraus 60 G, 4.51 | Gilman 58 G, 4.27 | |