| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 42-56 | King 15-29, 2.81 | Young 20-13, 2.18 | LeBoeuf 7-12, 2.72 | | | King 0 SV, 2.81 | King 45 G, 2.81 | Young 35 G, 2.18 | LeBoeuf 22 G, 2.72 | | 1885 49-48 | | | | | | | | | | | 1886 69-71 | McAdory 21-25, 4.94 | Moody 10-13, 5.58 | Yardley 7-6, 4.71 | Scanlon 3-3, 4.92 | Thorpe 7-4, 3.59 | Bailey 0 SV, 3.90 | McAdory 48 G, 4.94 | Reich 28 G, 4.45 | Moody 25 G, 5.58 | | 1887 81-58 | Thorpe 28-16, 2.51 | Kenyon 22-23, 4.05 | McAdory 29-17, 2.85 | Bey 0-1, 3.38 | Pelletier 2-1, 6.14 | Bey 1 SV, 3.38 | Thorpe 47 G, 2.51 | Kenyon 46 G, 4.05 | McAdory 46 G, 2.85 | | 1888 81-59 | Thorpe 25-19, 2.55 | Kenyon 27-17, 2.59 | McAdory 24-19, 2.28 | Bey 2-0, 0.78 | Bowens 1-0, 3.60 | Yardley 2 SV, 0.56 | Thorpe 48 G, 2.55 | Kenyon 47 G, 2.59 | McAdory 46 G, 2.28 | | 1889 63-69 | Thorpe 19-24, 2.59 | Kenyon 17-20, 3.07 | Montague 16-16, 2.83 | Keys 7-7, 2.25 | | Keys 1 SV, 2.25 | Thorpe 46 G, 2.59 | Kenyon 39 G, 3.07 | Montague 39 G, 2.83 | | 1890 78-62 | Kenyon 23-18, 3.16 | Thorpe 24-18, 3.33 | Montague 16-11, 3.73 | Keys 7-7, 3.96 | Carraway 0-0, 0.00 | Thorpe 2 SV, 3.33 | Thorpe 51 G, 3.33 | Kenyon 49 G, 3.16 | Montague 39 G, 3.73 | |