| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | DIX | 42 | 56 | .429 | 7th | 20 | 40-58 | 2 | .224 | 2.63 | .264 | | | 58,721 | $4,054 | $15,084 | | 1885 | DIX | 49 | 48 | .505 | 4th | 13½ | 48-49 | 1 | .263 | 4.27 | .288 | | | 76,942 | $4,054 | $15,084 | | 1886 | DIX | 69 | 71 | .493 | 4th | 30 | 67-73 | 2 | .291 | 5.26 | .312 | | | 70,527 | $4,054 | $15,084 | | 1887 | DIX | 81 | 58 | .583 | 3rd | 2 | 78-61 | 3 | .257 | 3.15 | .274 | | | 89,649 | $4,054 | $15,084 | | 1888 | DIX | 81 | 59 | .579 | 2nd | 16 | 82-58 | -1 | .264 | 2.44 | .267 | | | 90,187 | $4,054 | $15,084 | | 1889 | DIX | 63 | 69 | .477 | 4th | 20 | 63-69 | 0 | .240 | 2.76 | .252 | | | 59,194 | $4,054 | $15,084 | | 1890 | DIX | 78 | 62 | .557 | 3rd | 6 | 80-60 | -2 | .275 | 3.58 | .285 | | | 89,686 | $4,054 | $15,084 | |