| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | DIX | 47 | 51 | .480 | 4th | 15 | 51-47 | -4 | .242 | 2.66 | .281 | | | 67,554 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1885 | DIX | 56 | 42 | .571 | 2nd | 7 | 59-39 | -3 | .283 | 3.65 | .305 | | | 85,776 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1886 | DIX | 75 | 65 | .536 | 3rd | 24 | 78-62 | -3 | .289 | 4.39 | .328 | | | 106,150 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1887 | DIX | 81 | 57 | .587 | 2nd | 1½ | 73-65 | 8 | .266 | 3.51 | .303 | | | 106,721 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1888 | DIX | 58 | 82 | .414 | 7th | 39 | 60-80 | -2 | .232 | 2.93 | .309 | | | 82,832 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1889 | DIX | 61 | 78 | .439 | 6th | 25½ | 62-77 | -1 | .201 | 2.48 | .268 | | | 74,936 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1890 | DIX | 38 | 102 | .271 | 8th | 46 | 34-106 | 4 | .228 | 4.52 | .319 | | | 70,509 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1891 | DIX | 64 | 76 | .457 | 7th | 20 | 62-78 | 2 | .288 | 4.52 | .316 | | | 89,131 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1892 | DIX | 61 | 79 | .436 | 7th | 21 | 61-79 | 0 | .282 | 4.25 | .324 | | | 85,110 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1893 | DIX | 57 | 69 | .452 | 8th | 13½ | 54-72 | 3 | .274 | 4.24 | .318 | | | 75,526 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1894 | DIX | 62 | 64 | .492 | 6th | 10 | 58-68 | 4 | .278 | 3.84 | .310 | | | 80,357 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1895 | DIX | 65 | 61 | .516 | 3rd | 8 | 63-63 | 2 | .285 | 3.51 | .298 | | | 83,832 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1896 | DIX | 83 | 43 | .659 | 1st | - | 77-49 | 6 | .289 | 2.92 | .294 | | X | 100,723 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1897 | DIX | 73 | 53 | .579 | 4th | 9 | 76-50 | -3 | .279 | 2.79 | .281 | | | 103,076 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1898 | DIX | 59 | 67 | .468 | 5th | 15 | 60-66 | -1 | .282 | 3.55 | .293 | | | 73,021 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1899 | DIX | 70 | 56 | .556 | 4th | 6 | 73-53 | -3 | .294 | 3.18 | .283 | | | 101,885 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1900 | DIX | 67 | 59 | .532 | 2nd | 14 | 72-54 | -5 | .292 | 3.42 | .288 | | | 88,499 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1901 | DIX | 66 | 60 | .524 | 5th | 16 | 67-59 | -1 | .294 | 3.66 | .292 | | | 87,881 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1902 | DIX | 68 | 58 | .540 | 4th | 4 | 68-58 | 0 | .254 | 2.55 | .269 | | | 89,440 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1903 | DIX | 67 | 59 | .532 | 3rd | 9 | 63-63 | 4 | .238 | 2.47 | .281 | | | 94,236 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1904 | DIX | 90 | 50 | .643 | 1st | - | 88-52 | 2 | .268 | 2.48 | .278 | | X | 117,073 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1905 | DIX | 81 | 59 | .579 | 1st | - | 88-52 | -7 | .262 | 2.21 | .286 | | X | 116,853 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1906 | DIX | 74 | 66 | .529 | 4th | 13 | 71-69 | 3 | .251 | 2.45 | .283 | | | 116,199 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1907 | DIX | 72 | 68 | .514 | 4th | 7 | 80-60 | -8 | .264 | 2.56 | .277 | | | 115,954 | $7,681 | $23,002 | |