| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | DIX | 47 | 51 | .480 | 4th | 15 | 51-47 | -4 | .242 | 2.66 | .281 | | | 67,554 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1885 | DIX | 56 | 42 | .571 | 2nd | 7 | 59-39 | -3 | .283 | 3.65 | .305 | | | 85,776 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1886 | DIX | 75 | 65 | .536 | 3rd | 24 | 78-62 | -3 | .289 | 4.39 | .328 | | | 106,150 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1887 | DIX | 81 | 57 | .587 | 2nd | 1½ | 73-65 | 8 | .266 | 3.51 | .303 | | | 106,721 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1888 | DIX | 58 | 82 | .414 | 7th | 39 | 60-80 | -2 | .232 | 2.93 | .309 | | | 82,832 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1889 | DIX | 61 | 78 | .439 | 6th | 25½ | 62-77 | -1 | .201 | 2.48 | .268 | | | 74,936 | $7,681 | $23,002 | | 1890 | DIX | 38 | 102 | .271 | 8th | 46 | 34-106 | 4 | .228 | 4.52 | .319 | | | 70,509 | $7,681 | $23,002 | |