| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | DIX | 58 | 40 | .592 | 2nd | 4 | 56-42 | 2 | .269 | 2.22 | .258 | | | 89,575 | $7,164 | $22,449 | | 1885 | DIX | 43 | 55 | .439 | 7th | 20 | 54-44 | -11 | .279 | 3.36 | .291 | | | 95,378 | $7,164 | $22,449 | | 1886 | DIX | 99 | 41 | .707 | 1st | - | 98-42 | 1 | .333 | 3.84 | .307 | | X | 137,221 | $7,164 | $22,449 | | 1887 | DIX | 73 | 64 | .533 | 4th | 9 | 78-59 | -5 | .286 | 3.16 | .284 | | | 106,233 | $7,164 | $22,449 | | 1888 | DIX | 72 | 68 | .514 | 3rd | 25 | 70-70 | 2 | .228 | 2.61 | .284 | | | 99,872 | $7,164 | $22,449 | | 1889 | DIX | 85 | 51 | .625 | 1st | - | 86-50 | -1 | .238 | 2.17 | .251 | | X | 131,720 | $7,164 | $22,449 | | 1890 | DIX | 71 | 69 | .507 | 6th | 13 | 75-65 | -4 | .270 | 3.27 | .294 | | | 114,526 | $7,164 | $22,449 | |