| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | DIX | 50 | 48 | .510 | 3rd | 12 | 55-43 | -5 | .254 | 2.68 | .265 | | | 79,869 | $8,727 | $28,244 | | 1885 | DIX | 63 | 35 | .643 | 1st | - | 60-38 | 3 | .273 | 3.12 | .289 | | X | 99,929 | $8,727 | $28,244 | | 1886 | DIX | 83 | 57 | .593 | 2nd | 16 | 76-64 | 7 | .331 | 5.22 | .318 | | | 123,698 | $8,727 | $28,244 | | 1887 | DIX | 59 | 79 | .428 | 6th | 23½ | 56-82 | 3 | .262 | 4.71 | .305 | | | 96,543 | $8,727 | $28,244 | | 1888 | DIX | 70 | 70 | .500 | 5th | 27 | 73-67 | -3 | .239 | 2.46 | .288 | | | 96,722 | $8,727 | $28,244 | | 1889 | DIX | 84 | 53 | .613 | 2nd | 1½ | 81-56 | 3 | .246 | 2.35 | .251 | | | 149,692 | $8,727 | $28,244 | | 1890 | DIX | 81 | 59 | .579 | 2nd | 3 | 83-57 | -2 | .292 | 3.10 | .276 | | | 132,905 | $8,727 | $28,244 | |