| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1884 | DIX | 41 | 57 | .418 | 8th | 21 | 35-63 | 6 | .274 | 3.83 | .313 | | | 65,898 | $7,699 | $23,120 | | 1885 | DIX | 39 | 59 | .398 | 8th | 24 | 33-65 | 6 | .260 | 5.20 | .336 | | | 62,149 | $7,699 | $23,120 | | 1886 | DIX | 52 | 88 | .371 | 8th | 47 | 53-87 | -1 | .292 | 6.14 | .331 | | | 79,511 | $7,699 | $23,120 | | 1887 | DIX | 55 | 83 | .399 | 8th | 27½ | 55-83 | 0 | .257 | 4.05 | .316 | | | 85,006 | $7,699 | $23,120 | | 1888 | DIX | 72 | 68 | .514 | 4th | 25 | 65-75 | 7 | .276 | 3.37 | .302 | | | 93,304 | $7,699 | $23,120 | | 1889 | DIX | 57 | 86 | .399 | 8th | 31½ | 59-84 | -2 | .229 | 3.35 | .274 | | | 97,915 | $7,699 | $23,120 | | 1890 | DIX | 71 | 69 | .507 | 5th | 13 | 68-72 | 3 | .273 | 3.69 | .292 | | | 93,724 | $7,699 | $23,120 | |