| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1884 46-52 | Moody 20-17, 2.52 | Bush 16-18, 2.74 | Clements 7-17, 3.42 | Dillingham 2-0, 2.63 | Steele 0-0, 4.91 | Bush 0 SV, 2.74 | Moody 38 G, 2.52 | Bush 34 G, 2.74 | Clements 26 G, 3.42 | | 1885 50-47 | Bush 15-16, 4.90 | Dillingham 15-7, 4.00 | Brannock 1-0, 0.00 | Steele 4-2, 4.45 | | Steele 1 SV, 4.45 | Steele 63 G, 4.45 | Bush 37 G, 4.90 | Dillingham 33 G, 4.00 | | 1886 64-76 | Kessler 17-24, 5.91 | Morrill 15-22, 5.90 | Pinckney 18-21, 5.23 | Dillingham 0-1, 5.47 | Hearns 0-0, 0.00 | Dillingham 1 SV, 5.47 | Kessler 47 G, 5.91 | Morrill 46 G, 5.90 | Pinckney 44 G, 5.23 | | 1887 61-75 | Morrill 24-21, 4.20 | Kessler 18-23, 4.42 | Pinckney 15-25, 5.00 | Becker 0-2, 5.82 | Dillingham 2-2, 3.58 | Dillingham 5 SV, 3.58 | Kessler 46 G, 4.42 | Morrill 46 G, 4.20 | Pinckney 45 G, 5.00 | | 1888 62-78 | Kessler 20-26, 2.90 | Morrill 19-26, 2.74 | Grey 22-21, 2.16 | Burke 0-1, 7.20 | Clarke 0-0, 0.00 | Dillingham 2 SV, 4.41 | Kessler 47 G, 2.90 | Morrill 47 G, 2.74 | Grey 46 G, 2.16 | | 1889 62-75 | Kessler 26-25, 2.69 | Morrill 18-23, 2.72 | Grey 12-20, 3.30 | Clarke 3-6, 3.03 | Dillingham 1-0, 2.25 | Morrill 3 SV, 2.72 | Kessler 60 G, 2.69 | Morrill 60 G, 2.72 | Grey 39 G, 3.30 | | 1890 74-66 | Morrill 30-16, 3.05 | Kessler 25-25, 3.78 | Grey 11-14, 4.31 | Clarke 4-4, 3.82 | Dillingham 4-4, 1.73 | Clarke 3 SV, 3.82 | Kessler 62 G, 3.78 | Morrill 57 G, 3.05 | Grey 40 G, 4.31 | |