| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1883 61-37 | Horace 30-19, 1.86 | Kirkpatrick 31-18, 2.29 | Ford 0-0, 6.75 | | | Ford 0 SV, 6.75 | Horace 51 G, 1.86 | Kirkpatrick 50 G, 2.29 | Ford 3 G, 6.75 | | 1884 45-45 | Horace 19-14, 2.45 | Kirkpatrick 18-13, 2.57 | Wells 8-18, 4.31 | Keane 0-0, 27.00 | Ryan 0-0, 9.00 | Kirkpatrick 1 SV, 2.57 | Horace 39 G, 2.45 | Kirkpatrick 33 G, 2.57 | Wells 32 G, 4.31 | | 1885 41-71 | Horace 21-21, 3.03 | Wells 9-25, 4.49 | Wolff 10-23, 3.57 | Agee 1-2, 3.68 | Jarrell 0-0, 0.00 | Agee 1 SV, 3.68 | Agee 44 G, 3.68 | Horace 42 G, 3.03 | Wells 42 G, 4.49 | | 1886 48-93 | Ramsay 12-29, 4.31 | Young 13-25, 4.42 | Gilman 13-22, 3.93 | Horace 10-17, 4.64 | Jarrell 0-0, 0.00 | Gilman 1 SV, 3.93 | Gilman 53 G, 3.93 | Ramsay 51 G, 4.31 | Young 51 G, 4.42 | | 1887 47-86 | Ramsay 16-20, 4.11 | Horace 10-21, 4.90 | Gilman 8-19, 4.78 | Young 8-18, 4.55 | Abernathy 5-5, 3.93 | Abernathy 1 SV, 3.93 | Ramsay 55 G, 4.11 | Horace 48 G, 4.90 | Gilman 42 G, 4.78 | |