| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1887 52-86 | Cleveland 17-23, 4.13 | Gibbs 11-16, 3.89 | Moody 8-16, 4.56 | Webster 7-16, 5.19 | Woolridge 8-13, 4.61 | Cleveland 1 SV, 4.13 | Cleveland 46 G, 4.13 | Gibbs 44 G, 3.89 | Moody 44 G, 4.56 | | 1888 61-82 | Holbrook 17-19, 2.53 | Mulligan 11-22, 3.49 | Cleveland 16-16, 3.57 | Woolridge 10-12, 3.09 | Alleyne 7-9, 3.49 | Holbrook 2 SV, 2.53 | Holbrook 50 G, 2.53 | Mulligan 50 G, 3.49 | Woolridge 40 G, 3.09 | | 1889 71-69 | Beal 19-19, 3.78 | Carmichael 24-11, 3.29 | Holbrook 14-17, 4.88 | Mulligan 13-13, 3.73 | Albrecht 1-9, 7.52 | Albrecht 2 SV, 7.52 | Beal 43 G, 3.78 | Carmichael 42 G, 3.29 | Holbrook 38 G, 4.88 | | 1890 64-76 | Carmichael 18-18, 3.22 | Quarles 21-14, 3.03 | Pepperell 12-22, 4.32 | Loomis 10-17, 3.75 | Abernathy 0-0, 6.55 | Sutter 6 SV, 2.95 | Carmichael 45 G, 3.22 | Quarles 45 G, 3.03 | Sutter 39 G, 2.95 | |