| Name | Pos | Team | Age | DOB | POB | Nationality | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Salary | | Peabody, Roy | RF | Atlanta Peaches | 30 | 11/25/1862 | Darlington | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 195 lbs | $300 | | Pellegrino, Darby | RF | Louisville Stallions | 28 | 04/22/1865 | Allegheny Township | USA | Right | Right | 5' 6" | 175 lbs | $236 | | Petrillo, Levi | SP | Richmond Rebels | 28 | 05/05/1865 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 180 lbs | $438 | | Pickett, Nate | SP | Atlanta Peaches | 31 | 02/23/1862 | Temple | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 170 lbs | $207 | | Plemmons, Bill | SP | Nashville Chieftains | 28 | 05/05/1865 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 180 lbs | $350 | | Plummer, Jack | 3B | Louisville Stallions | 28 | 11/09/1864 | Kewanee | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 175 lbs | $236 | | Poirier, Alfred | CF | Louisville Stallions | 34 | 08/14/1859 | London | CAN | Left | Right | 5' 9" | 190 lbs | $320 | | Prescott, Abel | RF | Memphis Blue Stockings | 39 | 12/20/1853 | Braintree | USA | Right | Right | 5' 8" | 170 lbs | $156 | | Probst, Frank | RP | Nashville Chieftains | 23 | 10/07/1869 | Unknown | USA | Left | Left | 5' 6" | 185 lbs | $350 | | Purnell, Hank | 1B | Nashville Chieftains | 36 | 03/16/1857 | Boston | USA | Right | Right | 5' 9" | 175 lbs | $430 | |