BORDER ASSOCIATION
POSITIONAL STRENGTH OVERVIEW BY POSITIONS
11/01/1890
 
CATCHERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Sailors Art Brogan 1st 1st(tied) 1st
Cleveland Foresters Elmer McKinzy 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Brooklyn Kings Ed Monahan 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Chicago Cougars Lew Cormack 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Cincinnati Monarchs Herbert Bennett 5th 1st(tied) 5th
New York Stars Roy Randle 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Montreal Saints Theo Hubbard 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Toronto Provincials Bob Parkman 8th 1st(tied) 8th
FIRST BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Brooklyn Kings Alfred Marks 1st 1st(tied) 1st
Montreal Saints Clar Acheson 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
New York Stars Levi Mueller 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Cincinnati Monarchs Harry Hall 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Toronto Provincials Frank Harmon 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Chicago Cougars Gene Barrett 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Philadelphia Sailors Elmer Gleason 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Cleveland Foresters Oscar Curley 8th 1st(tied) 8th
SECOND BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Brooklyn Kings George Maroney 1st 1st(tied) 1st
New York Stars Jim Weldon 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Philadelphia Sailors Frank Hampton 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Cincinnati Monarchs Martin Bidwell 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Montreal Saints Tom Crockett 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Cleveland Foresters Lou Quinn 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Toronto Provincials Tim McGowan 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Chicago Cougars Chester Finney 8th 1st(tied) 8th
THIRD BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Cincinnati Monarchs Oscar Engel 1st 1st(tied) 1st
Brooklyn Kings George Rooney 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Chicago Cougars Oliver Cushing 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Cleveland Foresters Henri Bastien 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Philadelphia Sailors Percy Fretwell 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Montreal Saints Steve Benham 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Toronto Provincials Hal Simon 7th 1st(tied) 7th
New York Stars 8th 1st(tied) 8th
SHORTSTOPS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Chicago Cougars Ed Dobson 1st 1st(tied) 1st
Brooklyn Kings Silas Keane 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
New York Stars Ike Beall 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Philadelphia Sailors Frank McGrath 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Montreal Saints Silas Hance 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Toronto Provincials David Bickford 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Cleveland Foresters George Bridger 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Cincinnati Monarchs Elmer Sidgwick 8th 1st(tied) 8th
LEFT FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Brooklyn Kings Will Kuehn 1st 1st(tied) 1st
New York Stars Gene Ellerbe 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Philadelphia Sailors Charley Keeler 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Montreal Saints Clar Malloy 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Cleveland Foresters Bob Perry 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Monarchs Ben Hyde 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Chicago Cougars 7th (tied) 1st(tied) 7th(tied)
Toronto Provincials 7th (tied) 1st(tied) 7th(tied)
CENTER FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Sailors Ray Miser 1st 1st(tied) 1st
Montreal Saints Ed Ballard 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Cleveland Foresters Elias Renshaw 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Brooklyn Kings Gus Copeland 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Toronto Provincials Roy Forsyth 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Monarchs Art Derby 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Chicago Cougars 7th (tied) 1st(tied) 7th(tied)
New York Stars 7th (tied) 1st(tied) 7th(tied)
RIGHT FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Montreal Saints Walt Ray 1st 1st(tied) 1st
New York Stars Ray Lorenz 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Cleveland Foresters Fred Parmelee 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Toronto Provincials Walt Paris 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Chicago Cougars Jim Conner 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Monarchs Hugh Breckenridge 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Brooklyn Kings 7th (tied) 1st(tied) 7th(tied)
Philadelphia Sailors 7th (tied) 1st(tied) 7th(tied)
STARTING PITCHERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Brooklyn Kings Ray Hayden 1st 1st(tied) 1st
Montreal Saints Paul Dexter 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Philadelphia Sailors Herbert Harrison 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Cincinnati Monarchs Bernard Witter 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Toronto Provincials Elmer Townsend 5th 1st(tied) 5th
New York Stars Theo Heath 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Chicago Cougars Hugh Quarles 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Cleveland Foresters Walt Thistlethwaite 8th 1st(tied) 8th
RELIEVERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Cincinnati Monarchs Walt Kincaid 1st 1st(tied) 1st
New York Stars Theo Heath 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Cleveland Foresters Lou Gauthier 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Toronto Provincials Bob Brown 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Chicago Cougars Ben Sumlin 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Philadelphia Sailors Ed Reid 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Montreal Saints Sam Campbell 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Brooklyn Kings Roy Merriweather 8th 1st(tied) 8th
CLOSERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Montreal Saints Art Frost 1st 1st(tied) 1st
New York Stars Theo Heath 2nd 1st(tied) 2nd
Philadelphia Sailors Hank Ludlow 3rd 1st(tied) 3rd
Cleveland Foresters Walt Thistlethwaite 4th 1st(tied) 4th
Cincinnati Monarchs Clar Ashley 5th 1st(tied) 5th
Toronto Provincials Bob Brown 6th 1st(tied) 6th
Chicago Cougars Ben Sumlin 7th 1st(tied) 7th
Brooklyn Kings Roy Merriweather 8th 1st(tied) 8th
Monday, March 30th , 2026 - OOTP Baseball 27.1 Build 50