| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | | 1886 0-0 | Fischer 17-20, 3.00 | Crutchfield 17-21, 2.61 | Johnson 18-18, 2.39 | Murdock 0-5, 7.20 | Rucker 0-0, 2.83 | Walker 1 SV, 0.00 | Fischer 40 G, 3.00 | Crutchfield 39 G, 2.61 | Johnson 39 G, 2.39 | | 1887 0-0 | Crutchfield 7-27, 3.79 | Johnson 16-18, 3.48 | Chadwick 6-25, 3.97 | Fischer 13-13, 4.12 | Guess 0-0, 0.00 | Wofford 2 SV, 5.51 | Crutchfield 42 G, 3.79 | Johnson 40 G, 3.48 | Wofford 38 G, 5.51 | | 1888 0-0 | Crutchfield 16-46, 3.47 | Wofford 24-36, 2.81 | Johnson 4-4, 3.51 | Copley 2-0, 0.85 | Chadwick 1-0, 1.72 | Johnson 2 SV, 3.51 | Crutchfield 68 G, 3.47 | Wofford 65 G, 2.81 | Johnson 30 G, 3.51 | | 1889 0-0 | Copley 8-24, 4.51 | Wofford 12-18, 3.96 | Flowers 13-14, 2.82 | Fischer 10-13, 5.26 | Baker 8-14, 5.47 | Flowers 2 SV, 2.82 | Flowers 53 G, 2.82 | Copley 50 G, 4.51 | Wofford 45 G, 3.96 | | 1890 41-93 | Copley 14-23, 4.00 | Wofford 8-21, 5.02 | Reinhardt 6-19, 5.44 | Baker 4-18, 4.17 | Sellers 6-10, 3.21 | Wofford 1 SV, 5.02 | Wofford 46 G, 5.02 | Reinhardt 43 G, 5.44 | Copley 39 G, 4.00 | |