| Year | League | W | L | WPct | Finish | GB | Exp Rec | Diff | Avg | ERA | BABIP | Playoffs | Champion | Attendance | Payroll | Balance | | 1886 | FABL | 53 | 65 | .449 | 6th | 32 | 60-58 | -7 | .224 | 2.67 | .273 | | | 71,326 | $3,427 | $20,989 | | 1887 | FABL | 42 | 85 | .331 | 8th | 47 | 44-83 | -2 | .248 | 3.98 | .311 | | | 98,750 | $3,259 | $30,617 | | 1888 | FABL | 48 | 88 | .353 | 8th | 40 | 52-84 | -4 | .218 | 3.03 | .279 | | | 109,008 | $8,327 | $28,057 | | 1889 | FABL | 51 | 85 | .375 | 8th | 35 | 50-86 | 1 | .251 | 4.32 | .301 | | | 117,910 | $8,503 | $35,528 | | 1890 | PL | 41 | 93 | .306 | 8th | 43 | 42-92 | -1 | .234 | 4.24 | .294 | | | 185,599 | $9,039 | $47,623 | | 1891 | PL | 67 | 73 | .479 | 6th | 15 | 64-76 | 3 | .239 | 2.98 | .269 | | | 170,085 | $6,891 | $55,709 | |
