TORONTO PROVINCIALS
PITCHING LEADERS
11/01/1890
BNN Index | BA | SCORES | STANDINGS | STATS | TEAMS | PLAYERS | TRANSACTIONS | HISTORY
League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments
BRK | CHC | CIN | CLE | MON | NYS | PHS | TOR
Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers
TEAM PITCHING SINGLE SEASON LEADERS TEAM PITCHING CAREER LEADERS
140 IP required for season rate statistics. 350 IP required for career rate statistics.
ERA - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player ERA Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 1.33 1882  
2. Ernest Douglas 1.70 1882  
3. George Shelton 1.95 1885  
4. Walt Bollenbach 1.99 1888  
5. George Shelton 2.18 1884  
6. Frank McCabe 2.50 1886  
7. Herbert Vogel 2.65 1888  
8. Walt Pelletier 2.66 1884  
9. Walt Pelletier 2.77 1883  
10. Walt Pelletier 2.89 1885  
ERA - CAREER
Rank Player ERA IP  
1. Jasper Bonner 1.33 358.2  
2. George Shelton 2.64 885.2  
3. Walt Pelletier 2.78 806.1  
4. Frank McCabe 3.05 1413.0  
5. Elmer Townsend 3.15 392.0  
6. Walt Bollenbach 3.28 584.2  
7. Herbert Vogel 3.28 608.1  
8. Silas Clements 3.39 404.0  
9. Ernest Douglas 3.46 1119.2  
         
WINS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player W Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 28 1882  
2. Ernest Douglas 25 1882  
3. Frank McCabe 22 1889  
4. Frank McCabe 21 1886  
5. Frank McCabe 20 1888  
6. Silas Clements 20 1889  
7. Elmer Townsend 20 1890  
8. Walt Bollenbach 19 1889  
9. George Shelton 18 1885  
10. Frank McCabe 18 1887  
WINS - CAREER
Rank Player W IP  
1. Frank McCabe 81 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 52 1119.2  
3. Walt Pelletier 46 806.1  
4. George Shelton 43 885.2  
5. Walt Bollenbach 33 584.2  
6. Herbert Vogel 31 608.1  
7. Jasper Bonner 28 358.2  
8. Silas Clements 20 404.0  
9. Elmer Townsend 20 392.0  
10. Moses Dales 13 254.2  
LOSSES - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player L Year  
1. Art Leggett 39 1890  
2. Walt Downs 32 1890  
3. Ernest Douglas 29 1885  
4. Elmer Townsend 28 1890  
5. George Shelton 25 1886  
6. Frank McCabe 24 1889  
7. Silas Clements 24 1889  
8. Ernest Douglas 23 1883  
9. Frank McCabe 23 1887  
10. Walt Bollenbach 22 1889  
LOSSES - CAREER
Rank Player L IP  
1. Frank McCabe 85 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 83 1119.2  
3. George Shelton 56 885.2  
4. Walt Pelletier 49 806.1  
5. Art Leggett 39 368.2  
6. Herbert Vogel 33 608.1  
7. Walt Downs 32 333.0  
8. Walt Bollenbach 31 584.2  
9. Elmer Townsend 28 392.0  
10. Silas Clements 24 404.0  
WINNING PCT - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player WPct Year  
1. Jasper Bonner .718 1882  
2. Ernest Douglas .658 1882  
3. Walt Bollenbach .609 1888  
4. Frank McCabe .553 1886  
5. Herbert Vogel .531 1887  
6. George Shelton .519 1884  
7. Walt Pelletier .517 1884  
8. George Shelton .500 1885  
9. Frank McCabe .488 1888  
10. Ned Okereke .481 1883  
WINNING PCT - CAREER
Rank Player WPct IP  
1. Jasper Bonner .718 358.2  
2. Walt Bollenbach .516 584.2  
3. Frank McCabe .488 1413.0  
4. Herbert Vogel .484 608.1  
5. Walt Pelletier .484 806.1  
6. Silas Clements .455 404.0  
7. George Shelton .434 885.2  
8. Elmer Townsend .417 392.0  
9. Ernest Douglas .385 1119.2  
         
SAVES - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player SV Year  
1. Hank Sherrod 6 1883  
2. Harry Hamilton 6 1886  
3. Ray Browne 3 1890  
4. Nate Noyes 3 1885  
5. Jack Drake 2 1889  
6. Francis Smith 1 1884  
7. Jack Weaver 1 1889  
8. Dan McMahon 1 1882  
9. George Roberts 1 1888  
10. Bob Brown 1 1890  
SAVES - CAREER
Rank Player SV IP  
1. Harry Hamilton 6 31.1  
2. Hank Sherrod 6 30.0  
3. Ray Browne 3 63.2  
4. Nate Noyes 3 9.1  
5. Jack Drake 2 54.2  
6. Francis Smith 2 76.2  
7. Walt Bollenbach 1 584.2  
8. Bob Brown 1 52.2  
9. Johnny LaCaze 1 20.2  
10. Dan McMahon 1 66.0  
WAR - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player WAR Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 14.5 1882  
2. Frank McCabe 10.4 1886  
3. Walt Bollenbach 8.1 1889  
4. Silas Clements 8.0 1889  
5. Frank McCabe 7.7 1887  
6. Frank McCabe 7.6 1889  
7. Ernest Douglas 7.2 1882  
8. Elmer Townsend 7.2 1890  
9. Frank McCabe 6.9 1888  
10. George Shelton 5.7 1885  
WAR - CAREER
Rank Player WAR IP  
1. Frank McCabe 32.6 1413.0  
2. George Shelton 15.5 885.2  
3. Jasper Bonner 14.5 358.2  
4. Walt Bollenbach 12.4 584.2  
5. Ernest Douglas 11.4 1119.2  
6. Walt Pelletier 9.6 806.1  
7. Silas Clements 8.0 404.0  
8. Elmer Townsend 7.2 392.0  
9. Herbert Vogel 4.5 608.1  
10. Ike Shorter 3.5 280.1  
GAMES PITCHED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player G Year  
1. Silas Clements 51 1889  
2. Elmer Townsend 48 1890  
3. Art Leggett 47 1890  
4. Walt Bollenbach 47 1889  
5. Frank McCabe 46 1889  
6. Walt Downs 46 1890  
7. Frank McCabe 45 1887  
8. Herbert Vogel 43 1888  
9. Frank McCabe 42 1886  
10. Frank McCabe 41 1888  
GAMES PITCHED - CAREER
Rank Player G IP  
1. Frank McCabe 174 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 141 1119.2  
3. George Shelton 108 885.2  
4. Walt Pelletier 99 806.1  
5. Herbert Vogel 81 608.1  
6. Walt Bollenbach 80 584.2  
7. Francis Smith 53 76.2  
8. Silas Clements 51 404.0  
9. Dan McMahon 49 66.0  
10. Elmer Townsend 48 392.0  
GAMES STARTED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player GS Year  
1. Silas Clements 49 1889  
2. Art Leggett 47 1890  
3. Elmer Townsend 47 1890  
4. Walt Bollenbach 46 1889  
5. Walt Downs 46 1890  
6. Frank McCabe 46 1889  
7. Frank McCabe 41 1888  
8. Jasper Bonner 40 1882  
9. Frank McCabe 40 1886  
10. Frank McCabe 40 1887  
GAMES STARTED - CAREER
Rank Player GS IP  
1. Frank McCabe 167 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 141 1119.2  
3. George Shelton 105 885.2  
4. Walt Pelletier 99 806.1  
5. Herbert Vogel 72 608.1  
6. Walt Bollenbach 68 584.2  
7. Silas Clements 49 404.0  
8. Art Leggett 47 368.2  
9. Elmer Townsend 47 392.0  
10. Walt Downs 46 333.0  
COMPLETE GAMES - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player CG Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 36 1882  
2. Frank McCabe 35 1889  
3. Elmer Townsend 34 1890  
4. Ernest Douglas 34 1882  
5. Frank McCabe 33 1888  
6. George Shelton 32 1885  
7. Frank McCabe 31 1887  
8. Silas Clements 31 1889  
9. Ernest Douglas 31 1885  
10. Frank McCabe 29 1886  
COMPLETE GAMES - CAREER
Rank Player CG IP  
1. Frank McCabe 128 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 96 1119.2  
3. George Shelton 78 885.2  
4. Walt Pelletier 66 806.1  
5. Walt Bollenbach 49 584.2  
6. Herbert Vogel 48 608.1  
7. Jasper Bonner 36 358.2  
8. Elmer Townsend 34 392.0  
9. Silas Clements 31 404.0  
10. Art Leggett 29 368.2  
SHUTOUTS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player SHO Year  
1. Ernest Douglas 3 1882  
2. George Shelton 2 1884  
3. Frank McCabe 2 1889  
4. George Shelton 2 1885  
5. Frank McCabe 2 1886  
6. Silas Clements 2 1889  
7. Walt Bollenbach 1 1888  
8. Ernest Douglas 1 1885  
9. Walt Bollenbach 1 1889  
10. Walt Pelletier 1 1883  
SHUTOUTS - CAREER
Rank Player SHO IP  
1. Frank McCabe 5 1413.0  
2. George Shelton 5 885.2  
3. Ernest Douglas 4 1119.2  
4. Walt Bollenbach 2 584.2  
5. Silas Clements 2 404.0  
6. Walt Downs 1 333.0  
7. Walt Pelletier 1 806.1  
8. Herbert Vogel 1 608.1  
9. Oliver Acker 0 2.0  
10. George Blackstone 0 89.2  
INNINGS PITCHED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player IP Year  
1. Silas Clements 404.0 1889  
2. Elmer Townsend 392.0 1890  
3. Art Leggett 368.2 1890  
4. Frank McCabe 368.1 1889  
5. Walt Bollenbach 363.0 1889  
6. Jasper Bonner 358.2 1882  
7. Ernest Douglas 350.1 1882  
8. Frank McCabe 350.1 1887  
9. Frank McCabe 349.0 1886  
10. Frank McCabe 345.1 1888  
INNINGS PITCHED - CAREER
Rank Player IP IP  
1. Frank McCabe 1413.0 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 1119.2 1119.2  
3. George Shelton 885.2 885.2  
4. Walt Pelletier 806.1 806.1  
5. Herbert Vogel 608.1 608.1  
6. Walt Bollenbach 584.2 584.2  
7. Silas Clements 404.0 404.0  
8. Elmer Townsend 392.0 392.0  
9. Art Leggett 368.2 368.2  
10. Jasper Bonner 358.2 358.2  
HITS ALLOWED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player H Year  
1. Art Leggett 459 1890  
2. Silas Clements 427 1889  
3. Frank McCabe 414 1889  
4. Walt Bollenbach 411 1889  
5. Elmer Townsend 403 1890  
6. Ernest Douglas 398 1885  
7. Walt Downs 390 1890  
8. Frank McCabe 388 1887  
9. George Shelton 344 1886  
10. Ernest Douglas 330 1883  
HITS ALLOWED - CAREER
Rank Player H IP  
1. Frank McCabe 1387 1413.0  
2. Ernest Douglas 1321 1119.2  
3. George Shelton 865 885.2  
4. Walt Pelletier 832 806.1  
5. Herbert Vogel 577 608.1  
6. Walt Bollenbach 576 584.2  
7. Art Leggett 459 368.2  
8. Silas Clements 427 404.0  
9. Elmer Townsend 403 392.0  
10. Walt Downs 390 333.0  
HOME RUNS ALLOWED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player HR Year  
1. Herbert Vogel 16 1887  
2. Ernest Douglas 12 1884  
3. Walt Pelletier 12 1884  
4. Art Leggett 11 1890  
5. Walt Downs 11 1890  
6. Walt Pelletier 11 1885  
7. Silas Clements 11 1889  
8. Jack Weaver 8 1889  
9. Moses Dales 8 1887  
10. Herbert Vogel 8 1888  
HOME RUNS ALLOWED - CAREER
Rank Player HR IP  
1. Frank McCabe 26 1413.0  
2. Walt Pelletier 26 806.1  
3. Herbert Vogel 24 608.1  
4. Ernest Douglas 23 1119.2  
5. George Shelton 17 885.2  
6. Walt Bollenbach 11 584.2  
7. Silas Clements 11 404.0  
8. Walt Downs 11 333.0  
9. Art Leggett 11 368.2  
10. Rudolph Carter 8 228.0  
WALKS ALLOWED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player BB Year  
1. Walt Downs 156 1890  
2. Elmer Townsend 150 1890  
3. Art Leggett 137 1890  
4. Walt Bollenbach 132 1889  
5. Ike Shorter 132 1886  
6. Moses Dales 126 1887  
7. Herbert Vogel 125 1888  
8. Silas Clements 124 1889  
9. Herbert Vogel 121 1887  
10. Frank McCabe 109 1889  
WALKS ALLOWED - CAREER
Rank Player BB IP  
1. Frank McCabe 381 1413.0  
2. Herbert Vogel 246 608.1  
3. George Shelton 206 885.2  
4. Walt Bollenbach 185 584.2  
5. Ernest Douglas 170 1119.2  
6. Walt Pelletier 158 806.1  
7. Walt Downs 156 333.0  
8. Elmer Townsend 150 392.0  
9. Art Leggett 137 368.2  
10. Ike Shorter 132 280.1  
WALKS PER 9 IP - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player BB9 Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 0.5 1882  
2. Ernest Douglas 0.6 1882  
3. Walt Pelletier 1.1 1883  
4. Walt Pelletier 1.4 1884  
5. Ernest Douglas 1.6 1883  
6. George Shelton 1.7 1885  
7. Ernest Douglas 1.7 1885  
8. Ernest Douglas 1.8 1884  
9. George Shelton 1.9 1884  
10. Frank McCabe 2.1 1888  
WALKS PER 9 IP - CAREER
Rank Player BB9 IP  
1. Jasper Bonner 0.5 358.2  
2. Ernest Douglas 1.4 1119.2  
3. Walt Pelletier 1.8 806.1  
4. George Shelton 2.1 885.2  
5. Frank McCabe 2.4 1413.0  
6. Silas Clements 2.8 404.0  
7. Walt Bollenbach 2.8 584.2  
8. Art Leggett 3.3 368.2  
9. Elmer Townsend 3.4 392.0  
         
STRIKEOUTS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player K Year  
1. Frank McCabe 298 1886  
2. Jasper Bonner 230 1882  
3. George Shelton 193 1884  
4. Elmer Townsend 184 1890  
5. Ike Shorter 180 1886  
6. Walt Bollenbach 175 1889  
7. Walt Pelletier 167 1884  
8. Silas Clements 161 1889  
9. George Shelton 147 1886  
10. George Shelton 144 1885  
STRIKEOUTS - CAREER
Rank Player K IP  
1. Frank McCabe 714 1413.0  
2. George Shelton 484 885.2  
3. Walt Pelletier 378 806.1  
4. Walt Bollenbach 289 584.2  
5. Ernest Douglas 262 1119.2  
6. Jasper Bonner 230 358.2  
7. Herbert Vogel 216 608.1  
8. Elmer Townsend 184 392.0  
9. Ike Shorter 180 280.1  
10. Silas Clements 161 404.0  
STRIKEOUTS PER 9 IP - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player K9 Year  
1. Frank McCabe 7.7 1886  
2. George Shelton 6.8 1884  
3. Ike Shorter 5.8 1886  
4. Jasper Bonner 5.8 1882  
5. Walt Pelletier 5.8 1884  
6. Walt Pelletier 4.8 1883  
7. Walt Bollenbach 4.6 1888  
8. George Shelton 4.4 1886  
9. Walt Bollenbach 4.3 1889  
10. Elmer Townsend 4.2 1890  
STRIKEOUTS PER 9 IP - CAREER
Rank Player K9 IP  
1. Jasper Bonner 5.8 358.2  
2. George Shelton 4.9 885.2  
3. Frank McCabe 4.5 1413.0  
4. Walt Bollenbach 4.4 584.2  
5. Elmer Townsend 4.2 392.0  
6. Walt Pelletier 4.2 806.1  
7. Silas Clements 3.6 404.0  
8. Herbert Vogel 3.2 608.1  
9. Ernest Douglas 2.1 1119.2  
         
K/BB - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player K/BB Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 12.11 1882  
2. Walt Pelletier 4.23 1883  
3. Walt Pelletier 4.07 1884  
4. Ernest Douglas 3.83 1882  
5. George Shelton 3.57 1884  
6. Frank McCabe 3.39 1886  
7. George Shelton 2.29 1885  
8. Walt Bollenbach 2.15 1888  
9. Frank McCabe 1.69 1888  
10. George Shelton 1.65 1886  
K/BB - CAREER
Rank Player K/BB IP  
1. Jasper Bonner 12.1 358.2  
2. Walt Pelletier 2.4 806.1  
3. George Shelton 2.3 885.2  
4. Frank McCabe 1.9 1413.0  
5. Walt Bollenbach 1.6 584.2  
6. Ernest Douglas 1.5 1119.2  
7. Silas Clements 1.3 404.0  
8. Elmer Townsend 1.2 392.0  
9. Herbert Vogel 0.9 608.1  
         
WHIP - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player WHIP Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 0.80 1882  
2. Ernest Douglas 0.94 1882  
3. Walt Bollenbach 0.98 1888  
4. George Shelton 1.02 1885  
5. Frank McCabe 1.02 1886  
6. Frank McCabe 1.15 1888  
7. Walt Pelletier 1.18 1884  
8. George Shelton 1.19 1884  
9. Walt Pelletier 1.22 1883  
10. Herbert Vogel 1.27 1888  
WHIP - CAREER
Rank Player WHIP IP  
1. Jasper Bonner 0.80 358.2  
2. George Shelton 1.21 885.2  
3. Walt Pelletier 1.23 806.1  
4. Frank McCabe 1.25 1413.0  
5. Walt Bollenbach 1.30 584.2  
6. Ernest Douglas 1.33 1119.2  
7. Herbert Vogel 1.35 608.1  
8. Silas Clements 1.36 404.0  
9. Elmer Townsend 1.41 392.0  
         
OAVG - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player OAVG Year  
1. Jasper Bonner .188 1882  
2. Frank McCabe .203 1886  
3. Walt Bollenbach .205 1888  
4. Ernest Douglas .213 1882  
5. George Shelton .222 1885  
6. Herbert Vogel .234 1888  
7. Frank McCabe .236 1888  
8. George Shelton .242 1884  
9. Walt Pelletier .249 1884  
10. Walt Pelletier .255 1883  
OAVG - CAREER
Rank Player OAVG IP  
1. Jasper Bonner .188 358.2  
2. George Shelton .249 885.2  
3. Herbert Vogel .249 608.1  
4. Frank McCabe .252 1413.0  
5. Walt Pelletier .253 806.1  
6. Walt Bollenbach .255 584.2  
7. Elmer Townsend .261 392.0  
8. Silas Clements .265 404.0  
9. Ernest Douglas .273 1119.2  
         
OSLG - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player OSLG Year  
1. Jasper Bonner .232 1882  
2. Walt Bollenbach .275 1888  
3. Ernest Douglas .277 1882  
4. George Shelton .285 1885  
5. Frank McCabe .294 1886  
6. Herbert Vogel .305 1888  
7. Frank McCabe .316 1888  
8. George Shelton .330 1884  
9. Walt Pelletier .335 1883  
10. Elmer Townsend .338 1890  
OSLG - CAREER
Rank Player OSLG IP  
1. Jasper Bonner .232 358.2  
2. George Shelton .325 885.2  
3. Walt Bollenbach .335 584.2  
4. Frank McCabe .337 1413.0  
5. Elmer Townsend .338 392.0  
6. Walt Pelletier .345 806.1  
7. Herbert Vogel .351 608.1  
8. Ernest Douglas .365 1119.2  
9. Silas Clements .365 404.0  
         
OOPS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player OOPS Year  
1. Jasper Bonner .436 1882  
2. Ernest Douglas .510 1882  
3. Walt Bollenbach .527 1888  
4. George Shelton .553 1885  
5. Frank McCabe .553 1886  
6. Frank McCabe .593 1888  
7. Herbert Vogel .613 1888  
8. George Shelton .616 1884  
9. Walt Pelletier .616 1883  
10. Walt Pelletier .633 1884  
OOPS - CAREER
Rank Player OOPS IP  
1. Jasper Bonner .436 358.2  
2. George Shelton .621 885.2  
3. Frank McCabe .637 1413.0  
4. Walt Pelletier .638 806.1  
5. Walt Bollenbach .644 584.2  
6. Elmer Townsend .663 392.0  
7. Ernest Douglas .666 1119.2  
8. Herbert Vogel .672 608.1  
9. Silas Clements .680 404.0  
         
RWAR - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player rWAR Year  
1. Jasper Bonner 12.1 1882  
2. Frank McCabe 10.3 1886  
3. George Shelton 9.8 1885  
4. Ernest Douglas 8.5 1882  
5. Frank McCabe 7.8 1889  
6. Walt Bollenbach 7.1 1888  
7. Silas Clements 7.1 1889  
8. George Shelton 6.4 1884  
9. Walt Bollenbach 4.8 1889  
10. Frank McCabe 4.8 1888  
RWAR - CAREER
Rank Player rWAR IP  
1. Frank McCabe 27.1 1413.0  
2. George Shelton 20.0 885.2  
3. Jasper Bonner 12.1 358.2  
4. Walt Bollenbach 12.0 584.2  
5. Walt Pelletier 8.7 806.1  
6. Silas Clements 7.1 404.0  
7. Herbert Vogel 6.8 608.1  
8. Moses Dales 3.1 254.2  
9. Ike Shorter 2.3 280.1  
10. Elmer Townsend 2.2 392.0  
Powered by: Out of the Park Developments, Out of the Park Baseball, Franchise Hockey Manager
Monday, March 30th , 2026 - OOTP Baseball 27.1 Build 50