| Date | Player | Win Seasons | | | 1884 | Daniel Fallow | 30-14, 1.91 ERA, 410.1 IP, 29 BB and 89 K | | | 1884 | Otis Sheehan | 32-13, 1.68 ERA, 418.0 IP, 27 BB and 150 K | | | 1884 | Henry Moody | 20-17, 2.52 ERA, 336.1 IP, 36 BB and 103 K | | | 1884 | Gus McGuire | 26-16, 2.31 ERA, 392.2 IP, 34 BB and 156 K | | | 1884 | George Mulligan | 21-21, 2.35 ERA, 413.0 IP, 33 BB and 91 K | | | 1884 | Rufus Thomas | 23-12, 1.84 ERA, 342.2 IP, 37 BB and 83 K | | | 1884 | Henry Young | 20-13, 2.18 ERA, 310.1 IP, 31 BB and 56 K | | | 1884 | Ernie Kraus | 20-25, 2.72 ERA, 411.0 IP, 45 BB and 127 K | | | 1884 | Harvey Holmes | 22-22, 2.49 ERA, 412.2 IP, 48 BB and 85 K | | | 1885 | Daniel Fallow | 21-10, 3.28 ERA, 285.2 IP, 33 BB and 92 K | | | 1885 | Hiram Keys | 20-11, 3.35 ERA, 306.0 IP, 32 BB and 66 K | | | 1885 | Otis Sheehan | 20-13, 2.21 ERA, 313.2 IP, 43 BB and 173 K | | | 1885 | Gus McGuire | 27-16, 2.55 ERA, 378.1 IP, 61 BB and 263 K | | | 1885 | George Mulligan | 21-9, 2.43 ERA, 300.1 IP, 73 BB and 151 K | | | 1885 | Ernie Kraus | 21-10, 3.11 ERA, 292.2 IP, 31 BB and 147 K | | | 1885 | Nate Mahoney | 21-10, 3.81 ERA, 290.1 IP, 76 BB and 95 K | | | 1885 | Harvey Holmes | 25-20, 3.02 ERA, 394.0 IP, 84 BB and 157 K | | | 1886 | Pat Murphy | 34-9, 4.52 ERA, 394.2 IP, 36 BB and 68 K | | | 1886 | Otis Sheehan | 30-14, 3.06 ERA, 405.1 IP, 31 BB and 199 K | | | 1886 | George Mulligan | 32-11, 4.28 ERA, 382.2 IP, 124 BB and 151 K | | | 1886 | Rufus Thomas | 23-17, 6.13 ERA, 346.1 IP, 153 BB and 48 K | | | 1886 | Willis McAdory | 21-25, 4.94 ERA, 373.2 IP, 103 BB and 38 K | | | 1886 | Jim Weber | 29-11, 3.61 ERA, 368.2 IP, 57 BB and 101 K | | | 1886 | Ernie Kraus | 32-14, 3.54 ERA, 414.2 IP, 30 BB and 162 K | | | 1886 | Nate Pickett | 20-21, 4.48 ERA, 364.0 IP, 122 BB and 89 K | | | 1886 | Hank Lilly | 24-20, 4.32 ERA, 389.1 IP, 118 BB and 128 K | | | 1887 | Pat Murphy | 24-21, 3.48 ERA, 398.0 IP, 37 BB and 74 K | | | 1887 | Vic Montague | 21-22, 3.90 ERA, 381.0 IP, 78 BB and 123 K | | | 1887 | Otis Sheehan | 27-19, 2.49 ERA, 401.2 IP, 40 BB and 274 K | | | 1887 | George Mulligan | 28-15, 3.21 ERA, 398.0 IP, 96 BB and 236 K | | | 1887 | Willis McAdory | 29-17, 2.85 ERA, 410.2 IP, 70 BB and 100 K | | | 1887 | Jim Weber | 21-23, 3.30 ERA, 390.0 IP, 56 BB and 119 K | | | 1887 | Ernie Kraus | 28-16, 2.86 ERA, 409.0 IP, 45 BB and 159 K | | | 1887 | Steve Thorpe | 28-16, 2.51 ERA, 419.1 IP, 77 BB and 181 K | | | 1887 | Herbert Crosby | 20-21, 4.13 ERA, 361.1 IP, 120 BB and 76 K | | | 1887 | Nate Mahoney | 26-17, 3.66 ERA, 384.0 IP, 86 BB and 166 K | | | 1887 | Herbert Goodwin | 26-11, 3.71 ERA, 361.0 IP, 161 BB and 166 K | | | 1887 | Nate Pickett | 20-23, 3.99 ERA, 392.0 IP, 106 BB and 138 K | | | 1887 | Harvey Holmes | 20-23, 3.80 ERA, 397.2 IP, 116 BB and 146 K | | | 1887 | Will Morrill | 24-21, 4.20 ERA, 375.1 IP, 131 BB and 113 K | | | 1887 | Joe Whiteside | 29-15, 3.47 ERA, 379.0 IP, 120 BB and 134 K | | | 1887 | Vic Kenyon | 22-23, 4.05 ERA, 393.2 IP, 187 BB and 200 K | | | 1888 | Otis Sheehan | 30-18, 2.14 ERA, 420.2 IP, 42 BB and 220 K | | | 1888 | Gus McGuire | 22-23, 3.81 ERA, 399.1 IP, 51 BB and 149 K | | | 1888 | Willis McAdory | 24-19, 2.28 ERA, 394.2 IP, 58 BB and 147 K | | | 1888 | Jim Weber | 23-24, 2.88 ERA, 415.2 IP, 58 BB and 133 K | | | 1888 | Steve Thorpe | 25-19, 2.55 ERA, 423.2 IP, 56 BB and 190 K | | | 1888 | Herbert Crosby | 27-17, 2.90 ERA, 413.0 IP, 72 BB and 127 K | | | 1888 | Lew Townsel | 26-19, 2.40 ERA, 420.2 IP, 25 BB and 328 K | | | 1888 | Herbert Goodwin | 22-21, 2.99 ERA, 400.2 IP, 88 BB and 264 K | | | 1888 | Will Truitt | 25-13, 2.11 ERA, 414.0 IP, 50 BB and 366 K | | | 1888 | Fred Cathey | 26-16, 1.85 ERA, 414.0 IP, 63 BB and 390 K | | | 1888 | Pat Tuckett | 32-10, 2.02 ERA, 428.2 IP, 60 BB and 272 K | | | 1888 | George Grey | 22-21, 2.16 ERA, 387.2 IP, 146 BB and 311 K | | | 1888 | Joe Kessler | 20-26, 2.90 ERA, 410.1 IP, 119 BB and 226 K | | | 1888 | Vic Kenyon | 27-17, 2.59 ERA, 423.2 IP, 99 BB and 181 K | | | 1888 | Charley Pfeiffer | 29-11, 2.34 ERA, 373.2 IP, 71 BB and 237 K | | | 1889 | Pat Murphy | 22-9, 1.72 ERA, 288.0 IP, 34 BB and 54 K | | | 1889 | Otis Sheehan | 33-16, 1.82 ERA, 464.2 IP, 51 BB and 170 K | | | 1889 | Jim Weber | 22-22, 2.89 ERA, 411.0 IP, 51 BB and 136 K | | | 1889 | Lew Townsel | 35-15, 1.95 ERA, 461.1 IP, 20 BB and 258 K | | | 1889 | Will Truitt | 21-15, 2.37 ERA, 380.1 IP, 70 BB and 247 K | | | 1889 | Fred Cathey | 25-22, 1.80 ERA, 441.0 IP, 86 BB and 313 K | | | 1889 | Nate Pickett | 20-25, 2.23 ERA, 420.2 IP, 111 BB and 96 K | | | 1889 | Pat Tuckett | 26-13, 2.09 ERA, 400.2 IP, 89 BB and 237 K | | | 1889 | Joe Kessler | 26-25, 2.69 ERA, 454.1 IP, 137 BB and 169 K | | | 1889 | Charley Pfeiffer | 28-21, 2.56 ERA, 456.2 IP, 116 BB and 253 K | | | 1890 | Otis Sheehan | 29-18, 2.92 ERA, 456.0 IP, 58 BB and 154 K | | | 1890 | Gus McGuire | 24-18, 2.90 ERA, 406.0 IP, 69 BB and 78 K | | | 1890 | Steve Thorpe | 24-18, 3.33 ERA, 388.2 IP, 86 BB and 122 K | | | 1890 | Lew Townsel | 29-19, 2.12 ERA, 454.1 IP, 35 BB and 197 K | | | 1890 | Herbert Goodwin | 21-20, 3.21 ERA, 384.0 IP, 113 BB and 203 K | | | 1890 | Harvey Holmes | 22-19, 2.93 ERA, 395.2 IP, 91 BB and 90 K | | | 1890 | Will Morrill | 30-16, 3.05 ERA, 416.2 IP, 129 BB and 102 K | | | 1890 | Pat Tuckett | 23-16, 3.15 ERA, 366.0 IP, 117 BB and 158 K | | | 1890 | Joe Kessler | 25-25, 3.78 ERA, 426.2 IP, 131 BB and 105 K | | | 1890 | Vic Kenyon | 23-18, 3.16 ERA, 378.2 IP, 137 BB and 101 K | | | 1890 | Charley Pfeiffer | 32-13, 2.62 ERA, 430.0 IP, 140 BB and 230 K | | |
