| Date | Player | Win Seasons | | | 1876 | Pat Murphy | 24-9, 1.46 ERA, 296.0 IP, 7 BB and 35 K | | | 1876 | Chas Duffey | 22-12, 1.52 ERA, 289.1 IP, 20 BB and 34 K | | | 1876 | Daniel Fallow | 28-10, 1.85 ERA, 335.1 IP, 16 BB and 62 K | | | 1876 | Leo Miller | 21-11, 1.98 ERA, 296.0 IP, 7 BB and 33 K | | | 1876 | Paul Kennett | 25-8, 1.80 ERA, 294.2 IP, 22 BB and 52 K | | | 1877 | Pat Murphy | 21-10, 2.79 ERA, 274.1 IP, 19 BB and 83 K | | | 1878 | Jim Cannon | 23-5, 1.57 ERA, 253.0 IP, 21 BB and 180 K | | | 1878 | Buster Scott | 25-8, 1.23 ERA, 292.1 IP, 33 BB and 213 K | | | 1879 | Joe Cook | 22-17, 3.18 ERA, 351.1 IP, 31 BB and 46 K | | | 1879 | Rufus Riddick | 26-18, 2.59 ERA, 389.2 IP, 16 BB and 91 K | | | 1879 | Elmer Manuel | 20-6, 1.71 ERA, 242.2 IP, 26 BB and 147 K | | | 1879 | Hiram Whitman | 22-23, 2.95 ERA, 385.0 IP, 21 BB and 128 K | | | 1879 | Billy Roberson | 31-7, 1.39 ERA, 342.1 IP, 43 BB and 299 K | | | 1879 | Ezra Lockhart | 28-13, 2.15 ERA, 373.1 IP, 49 BB and 147 K | | | 1880 | Martin Tucker | 25-10, 1.64 ERA, 307.2 IP, 18 BB and 250 K | | | 1880 | Will Bullock | 22-10, 2.12 ERA, 255.0 IP, 39 BB and 239 K | | | 1880 | Edgar Kirkpatrick | 20-9, 1.10 ERA, 262.1 IP, 34 BB and 177 K | | | 1881 | Buster Scott | 26-17, 2.86 ERA, 374.2 IP, 100 BB and 89 K | | | 1881 | Rufus Riddick | 42-33, 2.79 ERA, 641.1 IP, 41 BB and 245 K | | | 1881 | Elmer Manuel | 20-10, 1.92 ERA, 263.0 IP, 53 BB and 174 K | | | 1881 | Martin Tucker | 22-21, 3.31 ERA, 383.2 IP, 50 BB and 95 K | | | 1881 | Will Bullock | 28-12, 2.95 ERA, 368.2 IP, 35 BB and 153 K | | | 1881 | Abel Kizzie | 21-8, 1.32 ERA, 258.2 IP, 43 BB and 172 K | | | 1882 | Michael Pitchford | 21-17, 2.52 ERA, 347.0 IP, 25 BB and 112 K | | | 1882 | Rufus Riddick | 25-19, 2.42 ERA, 379.0 IP, 26 BB and 176 K | | | 1882 | Martin Tucker | 30-13, 3.20 ERA, 365.2 IP, 17 BB and 99 K | | | 1882 | Will Bullock | 31-11, 2.76 ERA, 384.1 IP, 40 BB and 187 K | | | 1882 | Abel Kizzie | 34-11, 2.07 ERA, 399.2 IP, 22 BB and 175 K | | | 1883 | Martin Tucker | 23-25, 3.71 ERA, 412.0 IP, 55 BB and 57 K | | | 1883 | Will Bullock | 27-21, 3.00 ERA, 440.1 IP, 63 BB and 137 K | | | 1883 | Otis OBrien | 22-10, 2.46 ERA, 314.0 IP, 26 BB and 103 K | | | 1883 | Nate Chadwick | 32-19, 2.30 ERA, 453.2 IP, 44 BB and 240 K | | | 1883 | Cal Ames | 31-16, 2.06 ERA, 445.0 IP, 51 BB and 229 K | | | 1883 | Al Lynn | 26-8, 2.13 ERA, 303.2 IP, 31 BB and 122 K | | | 1883 | Billy Crutchfield | 20-11, 1.55 ERA, 284.2 IP, 40 BB and 159 K | | | 1884 | Otis OBrien | 27-14, 2.51 ERA, 373.1 IP, 35 BB and 194 K | | | 1884 | Walt Lopp | 20-21, 2.57 ERA, 371.0 IP, 81 BB and 204 K | | | 1884 | Nate Chadwick | 29-8, 1.56 ERA, 340.0 IP, 25 BB and 247 K | | | 1884 | Cal Ames | 30-11, 1.42 ERA, 360.2 IP, 38 BB and 255 K | | | 1884 | Al Lynn | 32-8, 1.63 ERA, 354.0 IP, 7 BB and 229 K | | | 1884 | Billy Crutchfield | 30-9, 1.97 ERA, 338.1 IP, 41 BB and 245 K | | | 1884 | Will Truitt | 20-15, 2.32 ERA, 299.0 IP, 51 BB and 154 K | | | 1885 | Edgar Kirkpatrick | 41-9, 2.02 ERA, 476.0 IP, 73 BB and 232 K | | | 1885 | Walt Lopp | 44-9, 1.97 ERA, 490.0 IP, 89 BB and 248 K | | | 1885 | Nate Chadwick | 24-18, 2.37 ERA, 364.2 IP, 33 BB and 171 K | | | 1885 | Cal Ames | 24-14, 2.47 ERA, 342.1 IP, 66 BB and 203 K | | | 1885 | Al Lynn | 23-14, 2.89 ERA, 330.2 IP, 65 BB and 82 K | | | 1885 | Dan LeBoeuf | 20-14, 2.18 ERA, 302.0 IP, 58 BB and 165 K | | | 1885 | Johnny Wallace | 25-14, 1.90 ERA, 346.1 IP, 90 BB and 179 K | | | 1886 | Jim Cannon | 24-18, 3.57 ERA, 371.0 IP, 91 BB and 139 K | | | 1886 | Edgar Kirkpatrick | 21-17, 3.05 ERA, 345.1 IP, 63 BB and 186 K | | | 1886 | Walt Lopp | 26-10, 3.02 ERA, 336.1 IP, 78 BB and 185 K | | | 1886 | Herbert Thayer | 28-13, 1.87 ERA, 385.0 IP, 47 BB and 255 K | | | 1886 | Dan LeBoeuf | 30-6, 1.88 ERA, 339.2 IP, 65 BB and 219 K | | | 1886 | Lew Anthony | 20-10, 1.96 ERA, 284.2 IP, 66 BB and 124 K | | | 1886 | Johnny Wallace | 23-14, 1.83 ERA, 330.0 IP, 73 BB and 149 K | | | 1886 | Gus Schneider | 29-6, 2.20 ERA, 315.2 IP, 54 BB and 158 K | | | 1886 | Judson Perry | 21-15, 1.74 ERA, 342.1 IP, 104 BB and 274 K | | | 1886 | Ike Silsby | 27-15, 2.30 ERA, 367.2 IP, 65 BB and 233 K | | | 1887 | Henry Page | 20-8, 2.28 ERA, 257.0 IP, 56 BB and 75 K | | | 1887 | Dan LeBoeuf | 25-9, 3.69 ERA, 317.1 IP, 86 BB and 118 K | | | 1887 | Silas Lawton | 22-12, 2.91 ERA, 324.2 IP, 114 BB and 77 K | | | 1887 | Johnny Wallace | 21-16, 3.05 ERA, 333.0 IP, 79 BB and 150 K | | | 1887 | Gus Schneider | 22-12, 3.09 ERA, 285.2 IP, 83 BB and 121 K | | | 1887 | Al McDonough | 21-21, 4.25 ERA, 355.2 IP, 71 BB and 54 K | | | 1887 | Judson Perry | 22-16, 3.16 ERA, 327.2 IP, 106 BB and 82 K | | | 1887 | Lou Jewett | 20-13, 3.38 ERA, 290.1 IP, 89 BB and 159 K | | | 1888 | Herbert Thayer | 38-22, 1.97 ERA, 553.0 IP, 113 BB and 264 K | | | 1888 | Lew Anthony | 20-23, 2.82 ERA, 392.0 IP, 105 BB and 123 K | | | 1888 | Lou Scudder | 29-11, 2.00 ERA, 351.2 IP, 105 BB and 205 K | | | 1888 | Gus Schneider | 43-22, 1.88 ERA, 574.0 IP, 77 BB and 336 K | | | 1888 | Al McDonough | 20-39, 3.18 ERA, 532.1 IP, 75 BB and 118 K | | | 1888 | Ray Flowers | 20-25, 3.24 ERA, 372.2 IP, 115 BB and 143 K | | | 1888 | Gene Wofford | 24-36, 2.81 ERA, 551.2 IP, 162 BB and 336 K | | | 1888 | Clyde Wilkes | 23-14, 1.86 ERA, 334.1 IP, 45 BB and 262 K | | | 1888 | Joe Chastain | 29-28, 2.44 ERA, 502.1 IP, 150 BB and 352 K | | | 1888 | Davey Hardy | 21-10, 3.01 ERA, 299.1 IP, 119 BB and 120 K | | | 1888 | George Beal | 36-25, 3.01 ERA, 555.1 IP, 119 BB and 171 K | | | 1888 | Len Darlington | 22-41, 3.89 ERA, 522.1 IP, 184 BB and 224 K | | | 1888 | Joe Ashford | 32-32, 2.44 ERA, 570.2 IP, 125 BB and 275 K | | | 1889 | Edgar Kirkpatrick | 32-3, 2.53 ERA, 337.2 IP, 106 BB and 183 K | | | 1889 | Lou Scudder | 23-10, 3.13 ERA, 270.2 IP, 137 BB and 143 K | | | 1889 | Jack Pendleton | 30-9, 1.83 ERA, 340.0 IP, 95 BB and 271 K | | | 1890 | Herbert Thayer | 20-15, 3.36 ERA, 321.0 IP, 114 BB and 81 K | | | 1890 | Gus Schneider | 20-17, 2.65 ERA, 316.1 IP, 68 BB and 102 K | | | 1890 | David Atwood | 24-14, 2.90 ERA, 353.2 IP, 96 BB and 107 K | | | 1890 | Ray Flowers | 28-10, 2.44 ERA, 357.2 IP, 100 BB and 211 K | | | 1890 | Lou Daley | 25-14, 2.64 ERA, 309.2 IP, 120 BB and 200 K | | | 1890 | Otto Hinz | 28-13, 2.45 ERA, 389.0 IP, 152 BB and 222 K | | | 1890 | Jack Pendleton | 22-14, 2.01 ERA, 317.2 IP, 130 BB and 166 K | | | 1890 | Ed Dalrymple | 20-14, 3.04 ERA, 314.0 IP, 132 BB and 143 K | | | 1890 | Harry Hartmann | 23-9, 1.91 ERA, 301.2 IP, 75 BB and 166 K | | | 1890 | Roy Blakely | 26-16, 2.51 ERA, 365.2 IP, 139 BB and 153 K | | | 1890 | Claude Coleman | 20-16, 2.56 ERA, 326.2 IP, 127 BB and 137 K | | | 1890 | George Satterfield | 23-12, 2.48 ERA, 330.1 IP, 119 BB and 141 K | | |