| Date | Player | Hits | |
| 04/27/1876 | Patrick O'Hanlon | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 3 RBI versus New York while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 05/16/1876 | Joe Whitcomb | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 6 RBI versus St. Louis while playing for Chicago | |
| 07/19/1879 | Frank Moorman | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 2 RBI versus Milwaukee while playing for Chicago | |
| 07/31/1879 | Lou Kerr | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 6 RBI versus Milwaukee while playing for New York | |
| 09/18/1879 | Art Gordon | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 4 RBI versus Milwaukee while playing for Cleveland | |
| 09/10/1881 | Cornelius Quimby | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 1 HR and 4 RBI versus Philadelphia while playing for Providence | |
| 06/26/1882 | Dan Colby | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 3 RBI versus Boston while playing for Baltimore | |
| 06/29/1882 | Alfred Elder | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 2 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Philadelphia | |
| 05/15/1884 | Steve Airington | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 2 RBI versus Providence while playing for Brooklyn | |
| 07/22/1884 | Dave Grigsby | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 1 RBI versus Providence while playing for Philadelphia | |
| 08/11/1884 | Willie Davis | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 2 RBI versus Brooklyn while playing for Boston | |
| 05/16/1887 | Frank Harmon | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 2 RBI versus Washington while playing for Buffalo | |
| 07/16/1889 | Alfred Dwyer | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 4 RBI versus Pittsburgh while playing for Chicago | |
| 07/03/1890 | Elmer Aubert | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 3 RBI versus Pittsburgh while playing for Washington | |
