| Name | Pos | Team | Age | DOB | POB | Nationality | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Salary | | Pace, Larry | 1B | Albany Legislators | 29 | 01/06/1864 | Philadelphia | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 190 lbs | - | | Parkman, Bob | C | Albany Legislators | 26 | 06/04/1867 | Hartsdale | USA | Right | Right | 5' 7" | 190 lbs | - | | Patterson, David | 2B | Hartford Colts | 26 | 01/17/1867 | Indianapolis | USA | Switch | Right | 5' 9" | 160 lbs | - | | Peery, Walt | SP | Providence Clippers | 22 | 04/28/1871 | Ligonier | USA | Left | Left | 6' 3" | 185 lbs | - | | Pepperell, Theo | RP | Buffalo Lake Captains | 25 | 07/17/1868 | Raynham | USA | Left | Left | 5' 11" | 175 lbs | - | | Perry, Douglas | 1B | Syracuse Salt Barons | 34 | 04/26/1859 | Unknown | IRL | Right | Right | 5' 7" | 175 lbs | - | | Peterson, Alex | 3B | Providence Clippers | 26 | 04/17/1867 | Covington | USA | Switch | Right | 6' 0" | 170 lbs | - | | Poole, Vic | CF | Jersey City Sparrows | 24 | 12/10/1868 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 190 lbs | - | | Pope, Harry | CL | Albany Legislators | 25 | 01/01/1868 | Providence | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 185 lbs | - | | Powers, Charles | 2B | Buffalo Lake Captains | 25 | 04/01/1868 | Baltimore | USA | Switch | Right | 6' 0" | 175 lbs | - | | Price, Bill | C | Syracuse Salt Barons | 24 | 10/25/1868 | Abington | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 190 lbs | - | | Price, Marcus | SP | Syracuse Salt Barons | 28 | 05/05/1865 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 175 lbs | - | | Purcell, Richard | C | Rochester Millers | 24 | 01/17/1869 | Bristol | USA | Switch | Right | 6' 0" | 190 lbs | - | | Purdy, Ernest | SS | Providence Clippers | 24 | 11/24/1868 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 185 lbs | - | |