| Name | Pos | Team | Age | DOB | POB | Nationality | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Salary | | Callahan, Martin | SP | Pittsburgh Hornets | 27 | 07/25/1863 | Unknown | IRL | Right | Right | 6' 4" | 180 lbs | $188 | | Cavanagh, Nate | SP | Pittsburgh Hornets | 25 | 10/09/1865 | Philadelphia | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 180 lbs | $188 | | Chastain, Joe | SP | Philadelphia Maroons | 27 | 10/29/1863 | New Orleans | USA | Right | Right | 6' 0" | 190 lbs | $925 | | Chatman, Al | CF | Baltimore Clippers | 23 | 10/30/1867 | Cleveland | USA | Right | Right | 6' 1" | 170 lbs | $700 | | Chisholm, Hank | C | Brooklyn Bigsbys | 25 | 08/26/1865 | Brooklyn | USA | Right | Right | 5' 6" | 145 lbs | $188 | | Churchill, Cal | C | Buffalo Buffaloes | 25 | 03/26/1865 | Burton | USA | Left | Right | 5' 6" | 165 lbs | $230 | | Clancy, Lew | 1B | Brooklyn Bigsbys | 31 | 09/29/1859 | New York | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 250 lbs | $550 | | Coady, Harry | C | Brooklyn Bigsbys | 26 | 09/11/1864 | Providence | USA | Left | Right | 6' 0" | 190 lbs | $260 | | Colby, Dan | RF | Brooklyn Bigsbys | 29 | 10/19/1861 | Brooklyn | USA | Right | Right | 5' 8" | 175 lbs | $188 | | Copley, George | RP | Buffalo Buffaloes | 23 | 12/25/1866 | Portsmouth | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 155 lbs | $188 | | Coughlin, Harry | RP | Buffalo Buffaloes | 20 | 08/02/1870 | Victoria | CAN | Left | Right | 6' 1" | 200 lbs | - | | Crooks, Theo | SP | Detroit Dynamos | 22 | 04/03/1868 | Poughkeepsie | USA | Right | Left | 5' 7" | 140 lbs | $550 | | Curtis, Clar | RP | Buffalo Buffaloes | 22 | 07/12/1868 | Brooklyn | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 175 lbs | - | |