| Name | Pos | Team | Age | DOB | POB | Nationality | Bats | Throws | Height | Weight | Salary | | Patrick, Abe | CF | Fort Wayne Cannons | 28 | 05/05/1865 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 180 lbs | $400 | | Patterson, Frank | SS | Toledo Tornados | 28 | 06/28/1865 | Detroit | USA | Right | Right | 5' 7" | 165 lbs | $246 | | Pelletier, Walt | SP | St. Paul Crusaders | 34 | 08/24/1859 | Guelph | CAN | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 185 lbs | $306 | | Peters, Ben | CF | Minneapolis Lumberjacks | 24 | 03/02/1869 | Cincinnati | USA | Right | Right | 5' 8" | 180 lbs | $364 | | Pfeiffer, Charley | SP | Kansas City Stars | 26 | 11/09/1866 | Columbus | USA | Right | Right | 5' 11" | 175 lbs | $270 | | Phelps, Art | C | Minneapolis Lumberjacks | 35 | 11/19/1857 | Bridgeport | USA | Right | Right | 5' 6" | 160 lbs | $206 | | Phillips, Robert | RF | Fort Wayne Cannons | 28 | 04/25/1865 | Unknown | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 190 lbs | $464 | | Piper, Herbert | RF | Fort Wayne Cannons | 26 | 06/20/1867 | Ridgway | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 185 lbs | $236 | | Pomeroy, Joe | RP | Kansas City Stars | 25 | 10/16/1867 | Newport | USA | Right | Right | 5' 10" | 175 lbs | $220 | | Pryor, Oliver | RP | St. Paul Crusaders | 26 | 05/29/1867 | Marcus Hook | USA | Right | Right | 5' 8" | 165 lbs | $362 | |