INDIANAPOLIS RED CAPS
PITCHING LEADERS
11/01/1899
BNN Index | WF | SCORES | STANDINGS | STATS | TEAMS | PLAYERS | TRANSACTIONS | HISTORY
League History Index | Players | Teams | Managers | Leagues | Leaderboards | Awards | Accomplishments
DM | FTW | IRC | KCS | MCC | MIN | STP | TOL
Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers
TEAM PITCHING SINGLE SEASON LEADERS TEAM PITCHING CAREER LEADERS
126 IP required for season rate statistics. 500 IP required for career rate statistics.
ERA - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player ERA Year  
1. Fred Cathey 1.53 1885  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 1.94 1885  
3. Jacob Lewis 2.05 1885  
4. Jacob Lewis 2.23 1884  
5. Ben O'Leary 2.25 1890  
6. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 2.39 1884  
7. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 2.53 1886  
8. Ben O'Leary 2.54 1888  
9. Lew Anthony 2.72 1884  
10. Fred Cathey 2.80 1886  
ERA - CAREER
Rank Player ERA IP  
1. Fred Cathey 2.48 928.2  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 2.83 1204.2  
3. Ben O'Leary 3.73 2570.1  
4. Ike Silsby 4.02 3873.1  
5. Denny McClister 4.05 698.0  
6. Jake Redmond 4.18 1028.0  
7. Fred Babcock 4.37 920.0  
8. Carney Kelleher 4.66 1086.1  
         
         
WINS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player W Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 37 1886  
2. Denny McClister 33 1891  
3. Fred Cathey 30 1886  
4. Ben O'Leary 28 1890  
5. Ben O'Leary 28 1891  
6. Carney Kelleher 27 1895  
7. Ike Silsby 26 1893  
8. Ike Silsby 25 1892  
9. Fred Babcock 25 1898  
10. Carney Kelleher 25 1894  
WINS - CAREER
Rank Player W IP  
1. Ike Silsby 236 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 163 2570.1  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 97 1204.2  
4. Carney Kelleher 77 1086.1  
5. Fred Cathey 74 928.2  
6. Jake Redmond 69 1028.0  
7. Fred Babcock 61 920.0  
8. Denny McClister 53 698.0  
9. Jacob Lewis 39 426.2  
10. Jack Conley 37 728.0  
LOSSES - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player L Year  
1. Ben O'Leary 24 1892  
2. Gerald Wilcox 24 1899  
3. Ike Silsby 22 1888  
4. Ike Silsby 21 1891  
5. Ben O'Leary 21 1888  
6. Ernie Shackelford 21 1898  
7. Ike Silsby 20 1890  
8. Ike Silsby 19 1892  
9. Ben O'Leary 19 1891  
10. Ike Silsby 19 1899  
LOSSES - CAREER
Rank Player L IP  
1. Ike Silsby 182 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 106 2570.1  
3. Carney Kelleher 44 1086.1  
4. Fred Babcock 43 920.0  
5. Jake Redmond 43 1028.0  
6. Jack Conley 39 728.0  
7. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 31 1204.2  
8. Denny McClister 27 698.0  
9. Gerald Wilcox 26 381.2  
10. Ernie Shackelford 25 410.1  
WINNING PCT - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player WPct Year  
1. Fred Cathey 1.000 1885  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .925 1886  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .917 1885  
4. Fred Cathey .909 1886  
5. Jacob Lewis .889 1885  
6. Ben O'Leary .800 1886  
7. Pat Rowe .789 1886  
8. Ike Silsby .741 1895  
9. Tom Corcoran .731 1894  
10. Ben O'Leary .718 1890  
WINNING PCT - CAREER
Rank Player WPct IP  
1. Fred Cathey .822 928.2  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .758 1204.2  
3. Denny McClister .662 698.0  
4. Carney Kelleher .636 1086.1  
5. Jake Redmond .616 1028.0  
6. Ben O'Leary .606 2570.1  
7. Fred Babcock .587 920.0  
8. Ike Silsby .565 3873.1  
         
         
SAVES - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player SV Year  
1. Hal Redfield 21 1888  
2. Pierre Bouchard 7 1889  
3. Hal Redfield 7 1889  
4. Joe Hewitt 6 1889  
5. Hal Redfield 6 1890  
6. Dan Foreman 5 1895  
7. Sherman Lenox 4 1886  
8. Hank Lilly 4 1889  
9. Hal Redfield 4 1893  
10. Dan Foreman 4 1899  
SAVES - CAREER
Rank Player SV IP  
1. Hal Redfield 44 278.1  
2. Pierre Bouchard 10 109.2  
3. Dan Foreman 10 250.2  
4. Joe Hewitt 9 158.0  
5. Wal Cole 5 42.1  
6. Sherman Lenox 5 89.1  
7. Fred Babcock 4 920.0  
8. Hank Lilly 4 68.2  
9. Tom McCord 4 209.1  
10. Tom Corcoran 3 303.2  
WAR - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player WAR Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 17.3 1886  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 13.5 1885  
3. Ben O'Leary 12.5 1890  
4. Jacob Lewis 10.7 1885  
5. Fred Cathey 10.6 1887  
6. Fred Cathey 10.5 1886  
7. Ben O'Leary 10.2 1891  
8. Fred Cathey 10.1 1885  
9. Ben O'Leary 8.8 1889  
10. Ben O'Leary 8.5 1887  
WAR - CAREER
Rank Player WAR IP  
1. Ben O'Leary 60.2 2570.1  
2. Ike Silsby 58.0 3873.1  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 44.9 1204.2  
4. Fred Cathey 31.3 928.2  
5. Carney Kelleher 16.3 1086.1  
6. Jake Redmond 15.4 1028.0  
7. Jacob Lewis 14.8 426.2  
8. Fred Babcock 12.3 920.0  
9. Denny McClister 7.7 698.0  
10. Hal Redfield 6.2 278.1  
GAMES PITCHED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player G Year  
1. Hal Redfield 72 1888  
2. Ike Silsby 67 1889  
3. Ben O'Leary 63 1889  
4. Hal Redfield 55 1889  
5. Jack Conley 53 1889  
6. John Hammond 52 1887  
7. Joe Hewitt 52 1889  
8. Ben O'Leary 51 1888  
9. Ben O'Leary 50 1890  
10. Ike Silsby 50 1892  
GAMES PITCHED - CAREER
Rank Player G IP  
1. Ike Silsby 501 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 364 2570.1  
3. Hal Redfield 209 278.1  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 151 1204.2  
5. Jack Conley 143 728.0  
6. Carney Kelleher 128 1086.1  
7. Jake Redmond 126 1028.0  
8. Fred Babcock 125 920.0  
9. Fred Cathey 118 928.2  
10. Joe Hewitt 109 158.0  
GAMES STARTED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player GS Year  
1. Ben O'Leary 48 1891  
2. Ike Silsby 48 1890  
3. Ike Silsby 47 1888  
4. Ben O'Leary 47 1892  
5. Fred Cathey 47 1887  
6. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 47 1887  
7. Ike Silsby 47 1892  
8. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 47 1886  
9. Ben O'Leary 47 1888  
10. Ike Silsby 46 1891  
GAMES STARTED - CAREER
Rank Player GS IP  
1. Ike Silsby 466 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 320 2570.1  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 151 1204.2  
4. Carney Kelleher 128 1086.1  
5. Jake Redmond 126 1028.0  
6. Fred Cathey 117 928.2  
7. Jack Conley 116 728.0  
8. Fred Babcock 109 920.0  
9. Denny McClister 81 698.0  
10. Jacob Lewis 50 426.2  
COMPLETE GAMES - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player CG Year  
1. Ben O'Leary 41 1891  
2. Denny McClister 40 1891  
3. Ike Silsby 35 1893  
4. Ike Silsby 35 1892  
5. Carney Kelleher 34 1895  
6. Ike Silsby 33 1899  
7. Ike Silsby 33 1891  
8. Ike Silsby 32 1898  
9. Gerald Wilcox 32 1899  
10. Ben O'Leary 31 1892  
COMPLETE GAMES - CAREER
Rank Player CG IP  
1. Ike Silsby 278 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 145 2570.1  
3. Carney Kelleher 95 1086.1  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 83 1204.2  
5. Jake Redmond 73 1028.0  
6. Fred Babcock 70 920.0  
7. Denny McClister 67 698.0  
8. Fred Cathey 49 928.2  
9. Jacob Lewis 43 426.2  
10. Gerald Wilcox 32 381.2  
SHUTOUTS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player SHO Year  
1. Fred Cathey 9 1885  
2. Jacob Lewis 7 1885  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 6 1885  
4. Fred Cathey 6 1886  
5. Ben O'Leary 6 1890  
6. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 5 1886  
7. Carney Kelleher 4 1897  
8. Ben O'Leary 4 1891  
9. Ben O'Leary 4 1888  
10. Ike Silsby 3 1899  
SHUTOUTS - CAREER
Rank Player SHO IP  
1. Ike Silsby 20 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 17 2570.1  
3. Fred Cathey 16 928.2  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 16 1204.2  
5. Jacob Lewis 8 426.2  
6. Carney Kelleher 7 1086.1  
7. Fred Babcock 5 920.0  
8. Denny McClister 4 698.0  
9. Jack Conley 3 728.0  
10. Jake Redmond 3 1028.0  
INNINGS PITCHED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player IP Year  
1. Ben O'Leary 422.2 1891  
2. Ike Silsby 407.0 1892  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 399.0 1886  
4. Denny McClister 392.1 1891  
5. Ben O'Leary 388.2 1892  
6. Ike Silsby 384.2 1891  
7. Ike Silsby 383.0 1890  
8. Ben O'Leary 380.0 1890  
9. Ike Silsby 374.2 1898  
10. Ike Silsby 374.0 1899  
INNINGS PITCHED - CAREER
Rank Player IP IP  
1. Ike Silsby 3873.1 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 2570.1 2570.1  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 1204.2 1204.2  
4. Carney Kelleher 1086.1 1086.1  
5. Jake Redmond 1028.0 1028.0  
6. Fred Cathey 928.2 928.2  
7. Fred Babcock 920.0 920.0  
8. Jack Conley 728.0 728.0  
9. Denny McClister 698.0 698.0  
10. Jacob Lewis 426.2 426.2  
HITS ALLOWED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player H Year  
1. Ike Silsby 437 1892  
2. Ben O'Leary 433 1892  
3. Ike Silsby 395 1890  
4. Ike Silsby 394 1899  
5. Ben O'Leary 391 1891  
6. Ernie Shackelford 389 1898  
7. Carney Kelleher 389 1895  
8. Carney Kelleher 386 1894  
9. Ike Silsby 384 1898  
10. Fred Babcock 383 1899  
HITS ALLOWED - CAREER
Rank Player H IP  
1. Ike Silsby 3856 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 2467 2570.1  
3. Carney Kelleher 1173 1086.1  
4. Jake Redmond 1028 1028.0  
5. Fred Babcock 986 920.0  
6. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 927 1204.2  
7. Fred Cathey 732 928.2  
8. Jack Conley 697 728.0  
9. Denny McClister 651 698.0  
10. Ernie Shackelford 452 410.1  
HOME RUNS ALLOWED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player HR Year  
1. Denny McClister 49 1891  
2. Ike Silsby 42 1891  
3. Ben O'Leary 27 1891  
4. Ben O'Leary 18 1889  
5. Robert Antonelli 18 1893  
6. Ike Silsby 17 1892  
7. Sam Grantham 16 1889  
8. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 13 1884  
9. Ike Silsby 13 1889  
10. Jack Conley 12 1890  
HOME RUNS ALLOWED - CAREER
Rank Player HR IP  
1. Ike Silsby 120 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 80 2570.1  
3. Denny McClister 57 698.0  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 29 1204.2  
5. Jack Conley 27 728.0  
6. Fred Babcock 24 920.0  
7. Jake Redmond 24 1028.0  
8. Sam Grantham 22 88.2  
9. Carney Kelleher 22 1086.1  
10. Robert Antonelli 21 357.2  
WALKS ALLOWED - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player BB Year  
1. Jack Conley 413 1889  
2. Ike Silsby 317 1889  
3. Ben O'Leary 250 1889  
4. Denny McClister 192 1891  
5. Jack Conley 191 1890  
6. Tom McCord 190 1889  
7. Carney Kelleher 182 1895  
8. Carney Kelleher 181 1894  
9. Gerald Wilcox 168 1899  
10. Robert Antonelli 166 1893  
WALKS ALLOWED - CAREER
Rank Player BB IP  
1. Ike Silsby 1501 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 872 2570.1  
3. Jack Conley 720 728.0  
4. Carney Kelleher 567 1086.1  
5. Jake Redmond 421 1028.0  
6. Fred Babcock 377 920.0  
7. Denny McClister 343 698.0  
8. Fred Cathey 322 928.2  
9. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 287 1204.2  
10. Tom McCord 226 209.1  
WALKS PER 9 IP - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player BB9 Year  
1. Lew Anthony 0.9 1884  
2. Jacob Lewis 1.3 1885  
3. Jacob Lewis 1.5 1884  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 1.5 1884  
5. Ike Silsby 1.6 1888  
6. Ben O'Leary 1.6 1888  
7. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 1.7 1885  
8. Ben O'Leary 2.1 1890  
9. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 2.2 1886  
10. Ben O'Leary 2.4 1893  
WALKS PER 9 IP - CAREER
Rank Player BB9 IP  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 2.1 1204.2  
2. Ben O'Leary 3.1 2570.1  
3. Fred Cathey 3.1 928.2  
4. Ike Silsby 3.5 3873.1  
5. Jake Redmond 3.7 1028.0  
6. Fred Babcock 3.7 920.0  
7. Denny McClister 4.4 698.0  
8. Carney Kelleher 4.7 1086.1  
         
         
STRIKEOUTS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player K Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 545 1886  
2. Fred Cathey 399 1887  
3. Denny McClister 376 1891  
4. Fred Cathey 366 1886  
5. Ben O'Leary 351 1890  
6. Ben O'Leary 346 1891  
7. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 326 1885  
8. Ike Silsby 317 1891  
9. Ben O'Leary 276 1889  
10. Fred Cathey 262 1885  
STRIKEOUTS - CAREER
Rank Player K IP  
1. Ben O'Leary 1653 2570.1  
2. Ike Silsby 1347 3873.1  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 1334 1204.2  
4. Fred Cathey 1029 928.2  
5. Denny McClister 471 698.0  
6. Carney Kelleher 427 1086.1  
7. Jack Conley 394 728.0  
8. Jacob Lewis 343 426.2  
9. Jake Redmond 343 1028.0  
10. Fred Babcock 324 920.0  
STRIKEOUTS PER 9 IP - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player K9 Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 12.3 1886  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 12.2 1885  
3. Fred Cathey 11.0 1887  
4. Fred Cathey 10.0 1885  
5. Fred Cathey 9.2 1886  
6. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 9.0 1884  
7. Jacob Lewis 8.6 1885  
8. Denny McClister 8.6 1891  
9. Ben O'Leary 8.5 1889  
10. Ben O'Leary 8.3 1890  
STRIKEOUTS PER 9 IP - CAREER
Rank Player K9 IP  
1. Fred Cathey 10.0 928.2  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 10.0 1204.2  
3. Denny McClister 6.1 698.0  
4. Ben O'Leary 5.8 2570.1  
5. Jack Conley 4.9 728.0  
6. Carney Kelleher 3.5 1086.1  
7. Fred Babcock 3.2 920.0  
8. Ike Silsby 3.1 3873.1  
         
         
K/BB - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player K/BB Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 7.24 1885  
2. Jacob Lewis 6.68 1885  
3. Lew Anthony 5.91 1884  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 5.82 1884  
5. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 5.68 1886  
6. Ben O'Leary 3.99 1890  
7. Jacob Lewis 3.74 1884  
8. Fred Cathey 3.69 1885  
9. Fred Cathey 3.18 1886  
10. Fred Cathey 3.00 1887  
K/BB - CAREER
Rank Player K/BB IP  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 4.6 1204.2  
2. Fred Cathey 3.2 928.2  
3. Ben O'Leary 1.9 2570.1  
4. Denny McClister 1.4 698.0  
5. Ike Silsby 0.9 3873.1  
6. Fred Babcock 0.9 920.0  
7. Jake Redmond 0.8 1028.0  
8. Carney Kelleher 0.8 1086.1  
         
         
WHIP - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player WHIP Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 0.77 1885  
2. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 0.91 1884  
3. Jacob Lewis 0.97 1885  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 0.97 1886  
5. Fred Cathey 0.98 1885  
6. Ben O'Leary 1.02 1888  
7. Ben O'Leary 1.02 1890  
8. Lew Anthony 1.05 1884  
9. Ike Silsby 1.08 1888  
10. Jacob Lewis 1.10 1884  
WHIP - CAREER
Rank Player WHIP IP  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 1.01 1204.2  
2. Fred Cathey 1.13 928.2  
3. Ben O'Leary 1.30 2570.1  
4. Ike Silsby 1.38 3873.1  
5. Jake Redmond 1.41 1028.0  
6. Denny McClister 1.42 698.0  
7. Fred Babcock 1.48 920.0  
8. Carney Kelleher 1.60 1086.1  
         
         
OAVG - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player OAVG Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .167 1885  
2. Fred Cathey .192 1885  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .195 1884  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .201 1886  
5. Ben O'Leary .216 1890  
6. Fred Cathey .222 1886  
7. Jacob Lewis .222 1885  
8. Fred Cathey .225 1887  
9. Denny McClister .225 1891  
10. Ben O'Leary .226 1888  
OAVG - CAREER
Rank Player OAVG IP  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .208 1204.2  
2. Fred Cathey .216 928.2  
3. Denny McClister .249 698.0  
4. Ben O'Leary .253 2570.1  
5. Jack Conley .261 728.0  
6. Jake Redmond .262 1028.0  
7. Ike Silsby .262 3873.1  
8. Fred Babcock .275 920.0  
         
         
OSLG - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player OSLG Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .219 1885  
2. Fred Cathey .261 1885  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .273 1886  
4. Jacob Lewis .287 1885  
5. Ben O'Leary .294 1890  
6. Fred Cathey .295 1886  
7. Fred Cathey .301 1887  
8. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .304 1884  
9. Jacob Lewis .308 1884  
10. Ben O'Leary .312 1888  
OSLG - CAREER
Rank Player OSLG IP  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .282 1204.2  
2. Fred Cathey .290 928.2  
3. Ben O'Leary .349 2570.1  
4. Jack Conley .355 728.0  
5. Jake Redmond .358 1028.0  
6. Ike Silsby .359 3873.1  
7. Fred Babcock .379 920.0  
8. Carney Kelleher .383 1086.1  
         
         
OOPS - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player OOPS Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .437 1885  
2. Fred Cathey .523 1885  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .531 1886  
4. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .535 1884  
5. Jacob Lewis .544 1885  
6. Ben O'Leary .565 1890  
7. Jacob Lewis .569 1884  
8. Ben O'Leary .583 1888  
9. Lew Anthony .589 1884  
10. Fred Cathey .589 1886  
OOPS - CAREER
Rank Player OOPS IP  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons .545 1204.2  
2. Fred Cathey .583 928.2  
3. Ben O'Leary .667 2570.1  
4. Jake Redmond .691 1028.0  
5. Ike Silsby .692 3873.1  
6. Denny McClister .720 698.0  
7. Fred Babcock .721 920.0  
8. Carney Kelleher .741 1086.1  
         
         
RWAR - SINGLE SEASON
Rank Player rWAR Year  
1. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 20.8 1886  
2. Fred Cathey 16.5 1886  
3. Fred Cathey 13.8 1885  
4. Ben O'Leary 13.2 1890  
5. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 12.9 1885  
6. Jacob Lewis 12.2 1885  
7. Ben O'Leary 11.7 1891  
8. Ike Silsby 10.8 1889  
9. Fred Cathey 10.2 1887  
10. Ben O'Leary 10.1 1889  
RWAR - CAREER
Rank Player rWAR IP  
1. Ike Silsby 73.8 3873.1  
2. Ben O'Leary 58.2 2570.1  
3. Alonzo Fitzsimmons 46.2 1204.2  
4. Fred Cathey 41.2 928.2  
5. Jake Redmond 18.0 1028.0  
6. Carney Kelleher 17.8 1086.1  
7. Jacob Lewis 15.9 426.2  
8. Denny McClister 12.5 698.0  
9. Fred Babcock 9.5 920.0  
10. Hal Redfield 7.2 278.1  
Powered by: Out of the Park Developments, Out of the Park Baseball, Franchise Hockey Manager
Monday, April 20th , 2026 - OOTP Baseball 27.1 Build 52