| Date | Player | Strikeouts | |
| 05/02/1885 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 16 K, 0 BB and 9.0 IP versus Toledo while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 05/05/1885 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 18 K, 4 BB and 9.0 IP versus Toledo while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 06/19/1885 | Fred Cathey | 15 K, 3 BB and 9.0 IP versus Des Moines while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 07/19/1885 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 15 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Des Moines while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 09/20/1885 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 16 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Minneapolis while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 05/03/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 15 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Milwaukee while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 05/22/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 17 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Des Moines while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 06/27/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 15 K, 2 BB and 9.0 IP versus Toledo while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 07/13/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 15 K, 2 BB and 9.0 IP versus Toledo while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 07/27/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 15 K, 3 BB and 9.0 IP versus Des Moines while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 08/08/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 19 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Milwaukee while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 08/28/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 15 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Des Moines while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 09/10/1886 | Alonzo Fitzsimmons | 17 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Milwaukee while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 06/24/1887 | Fred Cathey | 15 K, 4 BB and 8.1 IP versus Minneapolis while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 06/15/1890 | Jim Marchand | 15 K, 1 BB and 9.0 IP versus Toledo while playing for Fort Wayne | |
| 09/24/1890 | Ernest Beale | 15 K, 2 BB and 8.0 IP versus Fort Wayne while playing for Minneapolis | |
