| Date | Player | Hits | |
| 08/17/1885 | Marty Days | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 0 RBI versus Minneapolis while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 05/10/1886 | Lew Tierney | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 0 RBI versus Toledo while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 05/13/1886 | Frank Harmon | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 2 RBI versus Fort Wayne while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 06/11/1886 | Frank Harmon | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 2 RBI versus Toledo while playing for Indianapolis | |
| 09/12/1886 | Jack Rawlins | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 5 RBI versus Milwaukee while playing for Minneapolis | |
| 06/17/1891 | Jasper Milson | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 1 HR and 5 RBI versus St. Paul while playing for Fort Wayne | |
| 07/02/1892 | Ed Tilden | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 3 RBI versus St. Paul while playing for Fort Wayne | |
| 08/11/1892 | Jasper Milson | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 4 RBI versus Toledo while playing for Fort Wayne | |
| 08/16/1893 | Walt Trask | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 1 RBI versus Kansas City while playing for Milwaukee | |
| 07/17/1894 | Oscar Woolsey | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 1 RBI versus Milwaukee while playing for Minneapolis | |
| 08/22/1895 | Walt Trask | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 1 RBI versus Minneapolis while playing for Milwaukee | |
| 07/19/1901 | Hughie Wilson | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 2 RBI versus Denver while playing for St. Joseph | |
| 06/17/1903 | Felix Lee | 6 Hits in 7 AB, 1 RBI versus Omaha while playing for St. Paul | |
| 05/11/1906 | William Quincey | 8 Hits in 9 AB, 0 RBI versus Omaha while playing for St. Joseph | |
| 08/07/1906 | Pete Whitaker | 6 Hits in 6 AB, 2 RBI versus Omaha while playing for Indianapolis | |
