Ah, the Roaring Twenties. A time of excess that extended into pro sports. The number of teams attempting to get in on the professional football fun continued to rise. Much the same as what had happened in baseball in the previous century, the AFA President's office was now turning away clubs in an effort to keep the league to a "respectable" size. That size, going into the 1925 season, turned out to be 20 clubs. Sure, the revolving door continued to turn: out were the Minneapolis Lumberjacks, Evansville Lions and Kenosha Chiefs - all cities that many felt were too "small" for a big-time outfit. The grumbles coming out of places like Chicago and Detroit were that the AFA needed teams in the big east-coast cities had been heard as the New York Stars, Boston Minutemen, Baltimore Browns and Toronto Maple Leafs joined the circuit. That was largely due to the relaxation of the Blue Laws that had always prevented Sunday sporting events in those cities.
Once the teams hit the field, it became obvious that the big money held by those East Coast cities that had been denied membership in previous years was now powering some talented football clubs. The Cleveland Finches were named champions after posting a 12-1-1 mark, but it was not without controversy. The Baltimore Browns went 11-1-0 and Toronto went 10-1-1 while New York went 9-2-1. Baltimore loudly proclaimed that they should be the champs. As usual, Jack Kristich, AFA President stood firm on his decision, but it was clear that the power in the AFA now resided in the Eastern cities (even Philadelphia, playing a grueling schedule, posted a nice 11-5-4 record). The best "western" team was the Detroit Maroons - Rollie Barrell's boys went 8-4-1, good for sixth-place on the official league standings board.
For the first-time ever, the AFA League Office published an "All-Pro" list, similar to college football's All-America list, naming the most outstanding player at each position. Interestingly, Jack Kristich, who put the list together named halfback Hugh Ramsey, who hadn't played in the AFA since 1921 and was by then solely a barnstorming star, to the team. The 1925 All-Pro Team was:
Ends
- Lowell Chauvin, New York Stars
- Dave Stepien, Fort Wayne Titans
Tackles
- Bill Cooke, Chicago Wildcats
- Neil Robirds, Toledo Tigers
Guards
- Willie Smythe, Philadelphia Hornets
- Marco Weyh, New York Stars
Center
- Warner Victoria, Baltimore Browns
Quarterback
- Jack Barrell, Chicago Wildcats
Halfbacks
- Urban Dane, Chicago Wildcats
- Hugh Ramsey, All-South All-Stars
Fullback
- Doug Sadlier, New York Stars
FINAL STANDINGS
Team | W | L | T | PF | PA |
Cleveland Finches | 12 | 1 | 1 | 274 | 55 |
Philadelphia Hornets | 11 | 5 | 4 | 249 | 193 |
Baltimore Browns | 11 | 1 | 0 | 319 | 56 |
Toronto Maple Leafs | 10 | 1 | 1 | 174 | 39 |
New York Stars | 9 | 2 | 1 | 170 | 57 |
Detroit Maroons | 8 | 4 | 1 | 187 | 132 |
Chicago Wildcats | 8 | 8 | 1 | 156 | 145 |
Boston Minutemen | 6 | 5 | 1 | 141 | 149 |
Youngstown Reapers | 6 | 5 | 0 | 136 | 82 |
Toledo Tigers | 5 | 9 | 0 | 96 | 141 |
Pittsburgh Pros | 4 | 4 | 0 | 73 | 97 |
Akron Triangles | 3 | 4 | 1 | 66 | 80 |
Milwaukee Hawks | 2 | 1 | 0 | 22 | 28 |
Buffalo Nickels | 1 | 5 | 3 | 40 | 98 |
Fort Wayne Titans | 1 | 8 | 0 | 20 | 172 |
Gary Greys | 0 | 5 | 0 | 3 | 132 |
Duluth Navigators | 0 | 6 | 0 | 17 | 202 |
Rochester Robins | 0 | 7 | 0 | 30 | 139 |
Dayton Dusters | 0 | 8 | 0 | 10 | 85 |
Kansas City Steers | 0 | 8 | 0 | 26 | 127 |
WEEKLY RESULTS
Week | Day | Date | Visitor | Home | ||
1 | Sun | 20-Sep | Gary Greys | 0 | Detroit Maroons | 21 |
1 | Sun | 20-Sep | Chicago Wildcats | 0 | Youngstown Reapers | 14 |
2 | Sat | 26-Sep | Buffalo Nickels | 3 | Philadelphia Hornets | 21 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Toledo Tigers | 13 | Akron Triangles | 3 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Fort Wayne Titans | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 30 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Kansas City Steers | 7 | Milwaukee Hawks | 13 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Dayton Dusters | 7 | Youngstown Reapers | 14 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Gary Greys | 3 | Cleveland Finches | 17 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Rochester Robins | 7 | Pittsburgh Pros | 24 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Buffalo Nickels | 0 | Baltimore Browns | 17 |
2 | Sun | 27-Sep | Chicago Wildcats | 26 | Detroit Maroons | 0 |
3 | Sat | 3-Oct | Boston Minutemen | 7 | Philadelphia Hornets | 14 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Boston Minutemen | 6 | Baltimore Browns | 37 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Fort Wayne Titans | 3 | Toledo Tigers | 14 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Kansas City Steers | 0 | Akron Triangles | 23 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Duluth Navigators | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 30 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Dayton Dusters | 3 | Pittsburgh Pros | 14 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Chicago Wildcats | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 3 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Detroit Maroons | 3 | Youngstown Reapers | 20 |
3 | Sun | 4-Oct | Rochester Robins | 0 | Buffalo Nickels | 10 |
4 | Sat | 10-Oct | Pittsburgh Pros | 3 | Philadelphia Hornets | 23 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | New York Stars | 14 | Boston Minutemen | 14 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Youngstown Reapers | 7 | Milwaukee Hawks | 9 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Fort Wayne Titans | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 6 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Kansas City Steers | 3 | Toledo Tigers | 7 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Akron Triangles | 10 | Buffalo Nickels | 10 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Philadelphia Hornets | 14 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 14 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Gary Greys | 0 | Chicago Wildcats | 30 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Pittsburgh Pros | 0 | Baltimore Browns | 41 |
4 | Sun | 11-Oct | Duluth Navigators | 0 | Detroit Maroons | 42 |
5 | Sat | 17-Oct | New York Stars | 14 | Philadelphia Hornets | 3 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Dayton Dusters | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 7 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Kansas City Steers | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 30 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Baltimore Browns | 21 | Boston Minutemen | 0 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Akron Triangles | 10 | Pittsburgh Pros | 6 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Fort Wayne Titans | 14 | Buffalo Nickels | 7 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Toledo Tigers | 10 | Chicago Wildcats | 14 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Youngstown Reapers | 7 | Detroit Maroons | 16 |
5 | Sun | 18-Oct | Philadelphia Hornets | 6 | New York Stars | 17 |
6 | Sat | 24-Oct | Dayton Dusters | 0 | Philadelphia Hornets | 6 |
6 | Sun | 25-Oct | Akron Triangles | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 14 |
6 | Sun | 25-Oct | Kansas City Steers | 7 | Youngstown Reapers | 10 |
6 | Sun | 25-Oct | Chicago Wildcats | 3 | Cleveland Finches | 14 |
6 | Sun | 25-Oct | Rochester Robins | 7 | Detroit Maroons | 16 |
7 | Sat | 31-Oct | Fort Wayne Titans | 0 | Philadelphia Hornets | 27 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Rochester Robins | 13 | Boston Minutemen | 14 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Toledo Tigers | 0 | New York Stars | 24 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Fort Wayne Titans | 3 | Baltimore Browns | 38 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Gary Greys | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 27 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Milwaukee Hawks | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 14 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Philadelphia Hornets | 3 | Buffalo Nickels | 3 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Dayton Dusters | 0 | Akron Triangles | 7 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Youngstown Reapers | 3 | Chicago Wildcats | 16 |
7 | Sun | 1-Nov | Detroit Maroons | 41 | Duluth Navigators | 7 |
7 | Tue | 3-Nov | Buffalo Nickels | 0 | New York Stars | 13 |
8 | Sat | 7-Nov | Akron Triangles | 7 | Philadelphia Hornets | 17 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Toledo Tigers | 3 | Pittsburgh Pros | 6 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Fort Wayne Titans | 0 | New York Stars | 24 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Duluth Navigators | 3 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 27 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Detroit Maroons | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 28 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Buffalo Nickels | 0 | Boston Minutemen | 13 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Akron Triangles | 6 | Baltimore Browns | 20 |
8 | Sun | 8-Nov | Philadelphia Hornets | 12 | Chicago Wildcats | 0 |
8 | Wed | 11-Nov | Toledo Tigers | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 17 |
8 | Wed | 11-Nov | Rochester Robins | 0 | New York Stars | 17 |
9 | Sat | 14-Nov | Baltimore Browns | 28 | Philadelphia Hornets | 6 |
9 | Sun | 15-Nov | Dayton Dusters | 0 | Detroit Maroons | 10 |
9 | Sun | 15-Nov | Kansas City Steers | 0 | Youngstown Reapers | 17 |
9 | Sun | 15-Nov | Rochester Robins | 0 | Baltimore Browns | 45 |
9 | Sun | 15-Nov | Boston Minutemen | 14 | New York Stars | 17 |
9 | Sun | 15-Nov | Buffalo Nickels | 7 | Cleveland Finches | 7 |
9 | Sun | 15-Nov | Toronto Maple Leafs | 7 | Chicago Wildcats | 13 |
10 | Sat | 21-Nov | Toledo Tigers | 3 | Philadelphia Hornets | 17 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Duluth Navigators | 7 | Youngstown Reapers | 31 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Fort Wayne Titans | 0 | Pittsburgh Pros | 17 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Kansas City Steers | 6 | New York Stars | 10 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Dayton Dusters | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 13 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Toledo Tigers | 7 | Baltimore Browns | 14 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Detroit Maroons | 7 | Chicago Wildcats | 6 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Rochester Robins | 3 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 13 |
10 | Sun | 22-Nov | Philadelphia Hornets | 7 | Boston Minutemen | 23 |
11 | Thu | 26-Nov | Kansas City Steers | 3 | Toledo Tigers | 17 |
11 | Thu | 26-Nov | Cleveland Finches | 23 | Chicago Wildcats | 5 |
11 | Thu | 26-Nov | Detroit Maroons | 10 | Baltimore Browns | 7 |
11 | Thu | 26-Nov | Youngstown Reapers | 0 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 3 |
11 | Sat | 28-Nov | Detroit Maroons | 14 | Philadelphia Hornets | 14 |
11 | Sun | 29-Nov | Dayton Dusters | 0 | New York Stars | 14 |
11 | Sun | 29-Nov | Youngstown Reapers | 13 | Cleveland Finches | 14 |
11 | Sun | 29-Nov | Toledo Tigers | 6 | Boston Minutemen | 10 |
11 | Sun | 29-Nov | Fort Wayne Titans | 0 | Chicago Wildcats | 9 |
11 | Sun | 29-Nov | Philadelphia Hornets | 8 | Baltimore Browns | 27 |
12 | Sat | 5-Dec | Chicago Wildcats | 14 | Philadelphia Hornets | 14 |
12 | Sun | 6-Dec | Pittsburgh Pros | 3 | Toledo Tigers | 10 |
12 | Sun | 6-Dec | Baltimore Browns | 24 | Cleveland Finches | 10 |
12 | Sun | 6-Dec | Detroit Maroons | 7 | Boston Minutemen | 10 |
12 | Sun | 6-Dec | Chicago Wildcats | 7 | New York Stars | 6 |
12 | Wed | 9-Dec | Chicago Wildcats | 0 | Boston Minutemen | 20 |
13 | Thu | 10-Dec | Duluth Navigators | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 31 |
13 | Sat | 12-Dec | Toledo Tigers | 3 | Philadelphia Hornets | 10 |
13 | Sat | 12-Dec | Gary Greys | 0 | Cleveland Finches | 37 |
13 | Sat | 12-Dec | Chicago Wildcats | 6 | Toronto Maple Leafs | 12 |
13 | Sun | 13-Dec | New York Stars | 0 | Chicago Wildcats | 7 |
13 | Sun | 13-Dec | Philadelphia Hornets | 13 | Boston Minutemen | 10 |
14 | Sun | 20-Dec | Philadelphia Hornets | 14 | Toledo Tigers | 3 |